Re:Inside the world of longsword fighting
by Silhouette on Monday January 26, 2015 @06:53PM
(#8950440)
I'm genuinely curious now. Who downvotes a post like that instead of replying, and why? An aikidoka who doesn't like the idea that their art has significant downsides compared to others when it comes to real fights? Or maybe an aikido critic who doesn't like the idea that some of the skills it teaches are practically applicable in a real fight?
The downsides of aikido as a practical style are the same as many of the more intricate/interesting martial arts: they are far from including a complete set of skills for real fights, and it takes much longer to be proficient enough with their intricate techniques to actually use them than it does to get competent in train-by-actually-doing-it styles like boxing, judo, wrestling, etc.
Aikido does have the added disadvantage that being entirely defensive in nature, you only learn to defend against the level of attack you train with. Unsurprisingly, people who train in an entirely defensive style don't attack well without outside influence, which can lead to unfortunate delusions like being able to "catch a punch" that would last approximately one session training with anyone skilled in any decent striking style.