Re:Reddit implements "best" comment sorting based on score c...
by csbrooks on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @10:27AM
(#894707)
Not sure about that. This would tend to promote flame wars, and (on reddit) pun threads.
Re:Reddit implements "best" comment sorting based on score c...
by icefox on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @12:10PM
(#894924)
That isn't a very good sorting measure. It simply means you were the first one to comment.
You can game Hacker News currently this way. If there is already comments in a topic, don't start a new thread, instead reply to the top thread no matter what they said. You will get more replies and more votes.
Re:Reddit implements "best" comment sorting based on score c...
by there on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @11:41AM
(#894862)
but only for a lot of second-level children, not children of one reply. reddit's stupid pun threads usually have one reply after another as a staircase instead of many replies to one quality comment.
Re:Reddit implements "best" comment sorting based on score c...
by signa11 on Wednesday October 21, 2009 @12:36PM
(#894996)
i always liked gnus usage of scoring individual news articles by either subject/author etc etc. having that would be really nice.
just allow folks to score whatever/whoever they feel like, rather than foisting your version of 'goodness' on others. make low scoring articles fade into the background...
A comment that sparked a lot of conversation (has a lot of children) should be a good candidate for floating towards the top as well.