Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by cpach on Sunday January 25, 2015 @04:22PM
(#8944302)
Wouldn’t this possibility depend on security holes in Virtualbox rather than in the guest OS?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by thecatspaw on Sunday January 25, 2015 @04:37PM
(#8944366)
It would depend on both.
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by cpach on Sunday January 25, 2015 @05:14PM
(#8944468)
But if there are security holes in Virtualbox, wouldn’t they be exploitable by any OS, regardless of what language it was written in?
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by tedunangst on Sunday January 25, 2015 @08:32PM
(#8945123)
Yes. The relevance depends on how likely you are to run a virtualbox image you found on the Internet because somebody told you "run this image".
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by cbd1984 on Sunday January 25, 2015 @08:10PM
(#8945046)
The idea of a VM is that it provides an iron box which nothing can break out of, because it's completely invisible. There's nothing a guest can do which could possibly distinguish a VM session from running on the bare hardware. Partly this is for compatibility, partly for ease of development (develop the next VM as a guest in the current VM!), and partly for simple security: You can't escape a prison if you are utterly convinced you're already out.
Maybe that part of the theory never made it into practice.
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by tedunangst on Sunday January 25, 2015 @08:30PM
(#8945110)
Yeah. Welcome to practice: I type "ifconfig | grep vio" and if it comes back nonblank, I know I'm running in virtualbox.
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by cbd1984 on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:34AM
(#8945655)
OK. Is anyone working on x86 VMs which do try to be completely invisible to guests?
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by zaroth on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:42AM
(#8946054)
That was probably abandoned because it was not performant.
Re:Mezzanine: A Common Lisp-based 64-bit OS for VirtualBox
by cbd1984 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @05:07AM
(#8952251)
The idea of a VM is that it provides an iron box which nothing can break out of, because it's completely invisible. There's nothing a guest can do which could possibly distinguish a VM session from running on the bare hardware. Partly this is for compatibility, partly for ease of development (develop the next VM as a guest in the current VM!), and partly for simple security: You can't escape a prison if you are utterly convinced you're already out.
Maybe that part of the theory never made it into practice.