News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by mercer on Sunday January 25, 2015 @02:53PM (#8944018)
I find that whenever I'm inclined to unsympathetic to the experience of another person, it's best to stop and remind myself that most people try their best to be good and happy, and care for those that are close to them, and that perhaps I'm just missing something.

In this particular case, I'd argue that in many areas of the USA, cars are not a luxury, they're essential to moving around in the (to me) odd car-based infrastructure. Cell phones are also not a luxury, even here in Europe, which is why most homeless people have one. Kids are also not a luxury, because, as the author argues, context and basic human needs make it all but impossible for many (most) humans to keep from procreating, accidentally or otherwise.

I think it's intellectually lazy to apply your own situation to others without considering their particulars. Sure, there are times where you can conclude that someone 'deserves' their lot in life, but I've found much more often than not that this lot is a result of external factors, and concluding that it isn't is dangerous, arrogant, and easy.

Edit: I'd add that judging others in this manner often hinges on the assumption that willpower is somehow just a choice, where in actually there's a lot of evidence that it's not, at least in large part.

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by sametmax on Sunday January 25, 2015 @02:59PM (#8944041)
In theory yes, in practice, if you observe around you, people in debt are (very) often the ones with early children, loans, 200$ phone bills and more.

I've seen plenty people having money problems, even caused by health problems or accidents. The ones to get out of it are the ones that stop spending in materials everybody else claim are mandatory untill they get better.

And no, a cell phone is not mandatory. I lived without it for years.

And no, a car is not mandatory. If you are in an area requireing a car, move in another area. If you don't, you are making the explicit choice to spend more money for the luxury of staying here.

And no, accidental kids are not a good excuse when you got condom, pills, emergency pills and eventually abvortion. My GF had an abvortion once. It was terrible. Still better than having a family in distress.

Of course, you can always find extrems cases, like somebody raised in a very religious family, forced to keep a baby, or somebody with a love one to care in an hospital. But it's rare. I lived in Europe, Africa, travelled to Asia, America south and north. In the US or the West Europe, most people ARE, in fact, responsible for their debts.

I'm not talking about people in the street. These are a very different situation. I'm talking about this everyday poverty, that of course nobody choose to be in voluntarly, but are the results of life priorities directly imported from TV, magazins and supermarkets.

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by nitrogen on Sunday January 25, 2015 @03:56PM (#8944224)
If you are in an area requireing a car, move in another area.

Unfortunately in the US, areas that don't require a car are so much more expensive that you would be paying more not to have a car.

A lot of the reactions to poverty that would fix it have an "activation energy" that may not be available.

We must also always remember that dualistic free will is an illusion.

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by tormeh on Sunday January 25, 2015 @03:41PM (#8944173)
Remember that everything anyone ever did seemed like a good idea to them at the time. It's hard to remember, but true.
Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by sametmax on Monday January 26, 2015 @07:06AM (#8946572)
Yeah, you are right.
Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by silencio on Sunday January 25, 2015 @03:28PM (#8944126)
Are you in the US? Especially since the story is from someone living in the US?

> And no, a cell phone is not mandatory. I lived without it for years.

You get very few job interviews if you don't have a phone or internet connection (which your phone can help you with).

> If you are in an area requireing a car, move in another area.

Yeah, why doesn't everyone just pack up and move to a strange city with no guarantee of a job - if you can even find one with a better transit system (if you have money for that transit system in the first place) or a bike (if you have money for a bike) or walking (if your job prospects are good enough that you can walk to your job - _if_ you can walk in the first place).

> And no, accidental kids are not a good excuse when you got condom, pills, emergency pills and eventually abvortion. My GF had an abvortion once. It was terrible. Still better than having a family in distress.

Ignoring what happens to people that had kids before they had any problems... Because we don't also have a reproductive health crisis with Republicans trying to do away with abortions and very, very expensive condoms, pills, and emergency pills? Do you know how much that costs? The time? The actual money? Plan B is around $50. Pills (if they even work for you, which they don't for many women) can skyrocket even with insurance - and often they require a doctor's visit too which costs even more. Condoms? Free if you can find a place that has them for free, which is the difficult part. Abortion? Don't even get me started on the timing and money required for that.

Yes, people are responsible for their debts. That doesn't mean we treat them like shit, and that doesn't mean we can't have some kind of safety net/help for them. Everyone fucks up at some point or another, or shit happens. It's just easier for more privileged people to deal with that without losing everything they have.

> I've seen plenty people having money problems, even caused by health problems or accidents. The ones to get out of it are the ones that stop spending in materials everybody else claim are mandatory untill they get better.

This may be a very American problem, but hahahaha. Have you tried going without anything but the bare minimum to pay off $xx,xxx in medical bills - if you're lucky - after negotiating it down? One single relatively minor health problem/accident - or a major one with decent insurance - might be doable. Good luck with anything else though.

My middle class father is probably currently googling to figure out how to divorce my mother because his medical bills have risen in the past year despite being on Medicare+the best supplemental insurance on the market. Chew on that. What now, staying with his caring partner of decades and leaving her, me+my partner, and future grandkids an inheritance that isn't in the negatives is a privilege now? We as a society won't be better off continuing this kind of bullshit.

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by sametmax on Sunday January 25, 2015 @04:10PM (#8944264)
> Are you in the US? Especially since the story is from someone living in the US?

I live in France, where gaz is more expensive, and jobs are harder to get. I traveled to the US, I got american friends. I don't think my comparison in unfair.

> You get very few job interviews if you don't have a phone or internet connection (which your phone can help you with).

As I said before, you got your friends with phones and internet connection. You can get free internet connection in many places anyway, and use phone box. But you do realize people had job before we had cellphones and internet ?

Use your social skills. We are a human society, we are supposed to help each others. You are not alone.

> Yeah, why doesn't everyone just pack up and move to a strange city with no guarantee of a job

Yes you can. It's not the big deal everybody says it is. I changed countried. I changed language. Again, it beats staying in a place you can't afford. This idea you should die where you are born is not sane.

> if you can even find one with a better transit system (if you have money for that transit system in the first place) or a bike (if you have money for a bike)

You are talking extrem case. If you can afford 2 kids but not a $20 second hand bike (i Had many), you choose a very, very difficult life. The lady here has TWO kids. You can say she didn't choose the first one, but the second ?

> or walking (if your job prospects are good enough that you can walk to your job - _if_ you can walk in the first place).

Again, extrem case. Be honest, most people in debt are not legless.

> And no, accidental kids are not a good excuse when you got condom, pills, emergency pills and eventually abvortion. My GF had an abvortion once. It was terrible. Still better than having a family in distress.

> Ignoring what happens to people that had kids before they had any problems...

Again, you chose to have kids without creating any kind of buffer in case you have problems. It should not be done. People have kids like it's the "ok thing to do when you are in your 2O'". No, it's not. We are overpopulated, times are hard. Don't make kids until you are sure you can sustain them in the next 20 years, including if you have problems. Your society don't need more kids. Kids are a luxury. I understand you want to have them, but if you do, then get in trouble, you are responsible.

> Because we don't also have a reproductive health crisis with Republicans trying to do away with abortions and very, very expensive condoms, pills, and emergency pills?

Try is the proper word here. Cause last time I check, you can get condom for free very easily in any city.

> Do you know how much that costs? The time? The actual money? Plan B is around $50.

Yes, and it's not supposed to happens often. Twice in your life, $100. If more, again, you are responsible. I think $100 on 20 years is ok.

> Pills (if they even work for you, which they don't for many women) can skyrocket even with insurance - and often they require a doctor's visit too which costs even more.

Yes, that's expensive in the US and not in france. Goes for condom.

> Condoms? Free if you can find a place that has them for free, which is the difficult part.

Difficult ? Try most universities. Done.

> Abortion? Don't even get me started on the timing and money required for that.

It happens once in a while to one out 100 persons. Provided it happens to, and you already got not enough money to pay for it, and you have nothing you can save on in the 3 month you got to deal with it (it's starting to be some kind of bad luck, but let'ts play with the idea).You got 3 months to deal with it and find the money. You got help, programs, friends, associations. It's true it's harder, but you can do it. You are responsible for it.

And again, you are picking extrem case. When I had the abvortion with my GF, she was an illegal immigrant with no job nor money and I was a broke from the mali war. We dealt with it. Stop finding excuses for everything.

> Yes, people are responsible for their debts. That doesn't mean we treat them like shit,

I don't. Saying "you are responsible for that" is not treating them like shit. Not careing is not treating them like shit. I just speak my mind about what I think of this situation. I think it's a human thing to do.

> and that doesn't mean we can't have some kind of safety net/help for them.

Indeed. Society should be organised to prevent this to happend, then help when it failed. It's not incompatible with my personnal feeling about it as an individual.

> Everyone fucks up at some point or another, or shit happens. It's just easier for more privileged people to deal with that without losing everything they have.

I think all the poeple that downvoted my were more privileged that I was.

> This may be a very American problem, but hahahaha. Have you tried going without anything but the bare minimum to pay off $xx,xxx in medical bills - if you're lucky - after negotiating it down? One single relatively minor health problem/accident - or a major one with decent insurance - might be doable. Good luck with anything else though.

Man, I had malaria in Africa without health insurance. Don't even try, you can't compare.

> My middle class father is probably currently googling to figure out how to divorce my mother because his medical bills have risen in the past year despite being on Medicare+the best supplemental insurance on the market.

How did he get that medical bill ? Accident ? Disease ? How much responsible of his health is he ? If he is not, how statistically likely his situation can apply to people in general ?but

< Chew on that. What now, staying with his caring partner of decades and leaving her, me+my partner, and future grandkids an inheritance that isn't in the negatives is a privilege now? We as a society won't be better off continuing this kind of bullshit.

Quite the contrary. As long as people don't realize consomming, having kids and living the life we live is not a good bet on the future, society will be in trouble.

I'm not against helping people. I want people to take responsibility for their situtation. You are not a aids infected legless orphan in Senegal.

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by mercer on Monday January 26, 2015 @04:20AM (#8946143)
> I live in France, where gaz is more expensive, and jobs are harder to get. I traveled to the US, I got american friends. I don't think my comparison in unfair.

It is unfair. France, and Europe in general, is completely different when it comes to public transport. France also happens to have a much, much more solid 'social infrastructure' for those who are poor. Surely you understand that especially when we talk about poverty, 'socialist' France is very different from the USA?

> As I said before, you got your friends with phones and internet connection. You can get free internet connection in many places anyway, and use phone box. But you do realize people had job before we had cellphones and internet ?

Some people, especially among the poor don't really have friends (or no 'active' or nearby ones). Many places don't have phone boxes or free internet. And cellphones and internet changed a lot of things, so comparing our current world to a pre-internet, pre-cellphone world doesn't really make sense.

> Use your social skills. We are a human society, we are supposed to help each others. You are not alone.

Sadly, many people are alone. And social skills are partly acquired and perhaps even, to a degree, a luxury. I've worked jobs with people who were so busy that they didn't have time to practice their social skills or maintain friendships. In fact, the article touches on this too!

> Yes you can. It's not the big deal everybody says it is. I changed countried. I changed language. Again, it beats staying in a place you can't afford. This idea you should die where you are born is not sane.

Again, you're applying your personal experience to others. That's unavoidable to a degree, but assigning judgment based on personal experience is, in my view, one of the primary causes of suffering in the world. If what you're saying is true, the only conclusion is that you are a smart, crafty person and all those people who 'choose' to live in favelas or poor areas are idiots. Surely you don't really believe that?

> Again, extrem case. Be honest, most people in debt are not legless.

I've spent some time in areas where walking is outright dangerous, and walking to the nearest 'job' location would take about half a day. This it not uncommon in the USA. Nobody would hire you in such a situation.

> Again, you chose to have kids without creating any kind of buffer in case you have problems. It should not be done. People have kids like it's the "ok thing to do when you are in your 2O'". No, it's not. We are overpopulated, times are hard. Don't make kids until you are sure you can sustain them in the next 20 years, including if you have problems. Your society don't need more kids. Kids are a luxury. I understand you want to have them, but if you do, then get in trouble, you are responsible.

I agree in the abstract, but even just consider people who are born and raised in a setting where having kids is considered a 'duty' of sorts, which is pretty common. You can blame their environment or belief system, but can you blame them for not having the means, time, capacity, or influential people who make them change their beliefs?

> > Condoms? Free if you can find a place that has them for free, which is the difficult part. > Difficult ? Try most universities. Done.

Did you even read the article?

> Indeed. Society should be organised to prevent this to happend, then help when it failed. It's not incompatible with my personnal feeling about it as an individual.

That's fair enough (seriously). I just hope you're open to the idea that perhaps you might be wrong in your assessment. Because, honestly, most of what you say scares me, as I think beliefs like yours play a significant role in the ever-increasing hardness, selfishness, and smugness of society in regards its weakest members. I'm not saying you play an active role in this, don't get me wrong, but beliefs like the ones you express seem very harmful to me (even if they were true, and I don't think they are).

> I think all the poeple that downvoted my were more privileged that I was.

I think you should not assume such things.

> I'm not against helping people. I want people to take responsibility for their situtation. You are not a aids infected legless orphan in Senegal.

And you are not the standard by which we judge everyone else. It is a good thing that we don't have legless aids-infected orphans 'here'. And the reason why we don't have those is not because our legless, aids-infected orphans or their parents have chosen to better themselves. The reason why we don't have those is in part because we realize that people are not in full control of their situation, and through education, social 'security' (of various types) and such, we can improve things.

Suffering is a relative thing. I do not want to diminish your hardships, but I also don't see the point in judging the poor in our society based on the level of poverty in other societies.

Let me switch gears for a bit, as I think I'm not too interested in further discussing these specifics. We might just disagree on them, and it might not be all that productive to continue down this line.

The main reason I'm engaging with you is that I'm honestly curious why you feel a strong need to react against this article in the first place. Isn't it a good thing that we're trying to understand the difficulties and plight of the poor in our society? Isn't that generally a benefit? Shouldn't we do more of that? You even seem to agree that a big part of the problem is structural and societal, rather than personal.

I really mean it when I say that I'd like to understand. Personally, I've noticed that spending time 'immersed' in poverty has often caused me to actually dislike the poor. To feel that they're stupid. Perhaps that is why you feel this way, or perhaps not. But what I also noticed is that as I spent more time away from outright poverty and the 'stupidity' that seems to be part of it, my views would mellow a bit more, and as I studied the underlying reasons and mechanisms my sympathy would come back.

Yes, a lot of poor people do infuriatingly stupid things. In fact, my time among 'the poor' has made me often feel like I'm dealing with particularly stubbornly stupid children. And the fact that there is no 'inherent' sympathy (by blood or other ties) makes is difficult to deal with that sometimes. But I try my hardest these days to realize that if it is in fact true that these poor are 'grown children', then it should lead me to sympathize more, not less. And it makes me respect all the more people who do manage to climb out of poverty despite this fact. And it makes me respect people who try to change things both up close and from a distance. Because dear lord is it easier to sympathize with the poor if you don't have to be around them!

But that said, the one thing that I think is not really a good idea in any way, is to openly rail against children for being children. That seems rather pointless.

(not that I'm saying the poor are 'stubborn, stupid, children', by the way. I don't know if they are, and I think it's mostly irrelevant to our sympathies)

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by sametmax on Monday January 26, 2015 @07:12AM (#8946586)
> The main reason I'm engaging with you is that I'm honestly curious why you feel a strong need to react against this article in the first place. Isn't it a good thing that we're trying to understand the difficulties and plight of the poor in our society? Isn't that generally a benefit? Shouldn't we do more of that? You even seem to agree that a big part of the problem is structural and societal, rather than personal.

That can of settles it. You are definitly right on this. I think i reacted emotionally because I felt i lived a lot of thing people are complaining about and I'm tired about hearing complain and want them to move their ass.

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by mercer on Monday January 26, 2015 @08:41AM (#8946913)
That's good to hear. And I can understand that sentiment.
Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by intopieces on Sunday January 25, 2015 @03:54PM (#8944215)
"intellectually lazy" is the correct term, even a bit polite. The idea behind this discussion is to look at why people are poor and to find ways - real, concrete, actionable ways - to improve the situation for the poor. Judgements based on personal experience do not fit within this discussion because they are entirely beside the point.
Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by zo1 on Sunday January 25, 2015 @04:29PM (#8944340)
>"Judgements like 'well I was poor and now I'm rich - your story is fake' do not fit within this discussion because they are entirely beside the point."

That's obviously not what he is saying. Your doing way more than paraphrasing with that one.

Re:“Poor people don’t plan long-term. We’ll just get our hea... by intopieces on Sunday January 25, 2015 @05:33PM (#8944521)
I agree with you, so I changed it. I mischaracterized the person's comment. It was flippant and detracted from the point I was making.