Re:“I don’t think Wikipedia can be saved at this point, but ...
by guelo on Sunday January 25, 2015 @01:11PM
(#8943642)
Which sucks because the people that have the most time are those that are paid for their time. So that means that moneyed interests can push their messages via Wikipedia. And it will only get worse as more marketers realize this. In other words, Wikipedia is like every other medium out there. The reason Wikipedia works as well as it does is the same reason Google Search works as well as it does, for topics where there is no money it does a fair job.
That's really all it takes. Opinion-pushers can work completely within the rules of Wikipedia, and if they collectively have more time to dedicate to pushing their opinion than their opponents, they can use the Wikipedia process to push their view to the exclusion of others.
Arbitration and referendums are often ineffective against this; especially when long, long threads with lots of technical details, citations and counter-citations are involved, and when the arbitrators or referendum participants are themselves biased.
Most people just don't have the time or interest to read through long arguments. So arbitrarors and voters often make decisions with scant knowledge of what they're deciding on, or do so with a foregone conclusion in mind and without consideration of the evidence.
Frankly, I'm surprised that Wikipedia works as well as it does, and I still find it useful. But I just don't have the time or energy to endlessly fight off all the opinion pushers. As a consequence, I try to take what I read on Wikipedia with a big grain of salt.