In the 1980's the New Zealand government removed tariffs on imported cars leading to a massive growth in car ownership.
More cars leads to more driving and less cycling. Then, with more cars on the road, cycling becomes more dangerous.
This trend just happened to coincide with the change in helmet law.
Of course, I agree that if "less cyclists are on the road the less car drivers will be used to their presence and on the lookout for them."
"there was a 67% decline in serious traumatic brain injury (TBI) comparing data for the years nearest the helmet law (1988–1991 vs. 1996–1999)."
"Tin Tin et al6 list several reasons apart from the helmet law for declines in cycling rates and increases in cycling injuries. These include the lack of cycling focus in the New Zealand road safety agenda, an increase in children being driven to school due to parental concerns of safety and an already existing pre-law decline in cycling rates."
And ultimately a net decrease in head injuries doesn't mean that much when there are many other injuries with cycling generally being more dangerous.
I'm just a single data point but I stopped cycling in nz after they introduced the fines for being caught without a helmet. I've cycled daily in London for years now an it's a much safer place to cycle. My feeling is that's generally due to the awareness from having a lot of cyclists on the road. Whatever nz are trying to do with their foisting of rules upon people, it's not working.
Based on funding and who advocates these laws, a substantial amount of advocates are supporting them in order to clear the roads to promote motoring.
I'd say that's working just fine.
More cars and less cyclists ultimately results in less safe conditions for cyclists.
I'm actually astounded by this. I grew up in a fairly typical suburban neighborhood, and everybody walked to school. A few weeks before I started kindergarten, my mom walked me to school, to make sure I knew the way. The kids who got driven to school, were teased for it.
Today, every kid in that neighborhood gets driven. There's a long line of cars in front of the school, and the amount of traffic is cited as a reason why it's no longer safe to walk.
TL;DR "The following trends were observed following the introduction of New Zealand’s helmet law:
Cycling usage reduced by 51%. Cyclist’s injury risk per hour increased by 20–32%. Estimated to have contributed to 53 premature deaths per year (due to reluctance to cycle and hence people not exercising). Thousands of fines are issued annually for not wearing a helmet. May contribute to discrimination in accident compensation and the legal processes. Could have contributed to environmental pollution and environmental harm (due to use of vehicles in place of cycles). Possibly diminishes civil liberties and human rights (by imposing a requirement to wear a helmet when several reports raise serious doubts whether they improve safety overall)."