News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What should I do about YouTube? by ChuckMcM on Friday January 23, 2015 @03:55PM (#8937217)
Ok I think Zoe should create a t-shirt on tee spring with "I don’t think they are evil. I think they, like other tech companies, are just idealistic in a way that works best for them." that is such a great quote.

And I agree it is bogus what Google is asking. Next step is the ContentID equivalent robot that runs as a service and just sends DMCA takedown notices to Google forcing them to remove the videos and get no ad revenue on them and piss off their users. She really does have the power in this fight, applying it will take some effort but I think it can be done.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by AceJohnny2 on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:16PM (#8937319)
Yes, she's being very kind in her opinion, IMHO a bit too much. This sounds like something to be angry and up-in-arms about, but she's got other, closer battles to fight.

Another wonderful quote, regarding her past youthful tech idealism, is: "Unfortunately a lot of those ideals, if they still exist, have become…corrupted is too strong a word….subsumed. The revolution has been corporatized."

It's like the post-hippie era all over again. Someone page Gil Scott-Heron's ghost, we need an update to his poem.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by tod222 on Saturday January 24, 2015 @12:28AM (#8938909)
> "…corrupted is too strong a word….subsumed."

She is being extremely generous. Corrupted is exactly the right word.

The parent comment highlights the two sentences starting with "I don’t think they are evil." But I was particularly struck by the end of that paragraph:

"The people who work at Google, Facebook, etc can’t imagine how everything they make is not, like, totally awesome. If it’s not awesome for you it’s because you just don’t understand it yet and you’ll come around. They can’t imagine scenarios outside their reality and that is how they inadvertently unleash things like the algorithmic cruelty of Facebook’s yearly review (which showed me a picture I had posted after a doctor told me my husband had 6-8 weeks to live)."

Algorithmic cruelty is such a great turn of phrase.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by icebraining on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:15PM (#8937310)
Next step is the ContentID equivalent robot that runs as a service and just sends DMCA takedown notices to Google forcing them to remove the videos and get no ad revenue on them and piss off their users.

Yeah, but the problem is that those users are often her fans, and they'll be pissed at her too. And the fact is that she has more to lose than Google, no matter what she does.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by twic on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:48PM (#8937504)
What if the robot sent the video's poster a message saying "Hey, you're using my music without my permission. If you put on an annotation crediting it to me and linking it to my Bandcamp page, i'll give you my permission. But if you don't, i'll DMCA you."?

Essentially, you'd be implementing the earlier, non-evil, version of the Content ID program yourself.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by tempestn on Friday January 23, 2015 @05:12PM (#8937656)
Good idea, but it could be phrased a lot more amicably. Maybe, "Hi, I'm really happy you like [song name]. Just writing to let you know that you're entirely welcome to use the song in this video, free of charge, as long as you add an annotation crediting me (Zoe Keating) and linking back to my Bandcamp page (URL). Here's an article describing how to do that: [link]. Thanks!"
Re:What should I do about YouTube? by twic on Friday January 23, 2015 @06:46PM (#8938104)
Yes, that seems good. A modest revision:

"FOOL! You dare to use my music on your worthless trinket of a video? Demonstrate your complete submission to my will by adding credits and a link, as directed [link], and I may spare your pitiful life. KNEEL BEFORE ZOË!"

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by protomyth on Saturday January 24, 2015 @10:37AM (#8939832)
Depending on the musician / band that actually might be the proper tone for the message. Probably not for this artist, but I can think of a few that the fan would get a kick out of that response.
Re:What should I do about YouTube? by ChuckMcM on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:36PM (#8937435)
I think she describes it pretty well in the blog post, she uses the existing ContentID system which effectively DMCA's the video user internally and then gives them the option of adding Google advertising or taking it down.

From the user's perspective, the change would be "Go here ... and request a sync license to this music content." rather than a checkbox to just turn on Google advertising. If they didn't want to do that then they would need to take down the video.

She is already sending auto-takedowns, Google simply wants to double dip on the value, both getting advertising revenue from her work when fans use it in their videos and using it to attract more customers to their music service by giving her songs away for free when it pleases them.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by magicalist on Friday January 23, 2015 @05:01PM (#8937588)
> giving her songs away for free when it pleases them.

It's not free, it's the paid youtube service they're going to offer:

http://arstechnica.com/business/2014/06/artists-who-dont-sig...

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by ChuckMcM on Friday January 23, 2015 @06:18PM (#8938002)
From that very article: ... if labels can't agree to make their videos available to both the free and premium tiers of the subscription service.

You need only look at the Amazon Prime Music service as an exemplar, take an artist, make a couple of recognizable hits available for 'free', and the rest behind the service paywall. That is a pretty classic and well used content service feature for attracting new customers, only the content service decides what to give away for free, and what to charge for, not the artist. And if you read closely the original article Zoe said she had to put it on Google's service at the exact same time she did anywhere else. This is a huge loss in marketing leverage for a small artist because she loses the ability to have a special "fan release" that she can get out early to fans to subscribe to her own version of an affinity service.

So lets say she produces an awesome track, and her fans are all abuzz because they hear it first. It pulls people on the edge into the fan subscription service.

But with this arrangement all of that marketing leverage is ceded to Google. They might decide to put her best paying track on the 'free' side to highlight great indie artist tunes on the 'pay' side. She loses her best source of revenue and Google gets to push some people over the edge into paying for their streaming service.

Artistic content, whether it is games, movies, music, or books, has a strong 'freshness' peak in value when it first comes out and then tapers off rapidly. Collecting that value is fundamental to the economics of information, that is why there are "exclusive" stories and "sneak previews".

Google is requesting that artists cede that value over to them in order to participate on Youtube. In my opinion, that is an exceptionally high price to pay.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by towelguy on Saturday January 24, 2015 @10:58AM (#8939902)
She could make a song telling her fans to upload their videos to vimeo instead of youtube.
Re:What should I do about YouTube? by magicalist on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:10PM (#8937288)
> Next step is the ContentID equivalent robot that runs as a service and just sends DMCA takedown notices to Google forcing them to remove the videos and get no ad revenue on them and piss off their users

You just described dozens (hundreds?) of scammy "infringement detection" companies that already exist :) e.g https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8867496

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by bambax on Friday January 23, 2015 @06:08PM (#8937956)
ContentID stores some kind of hash to identify music; isn't this "hash" just another version of the same work and therefore subject to copyright?

My point is it's likely that ContentID needs some kind of permission from the artist to even work, because in order to identify someone's music it needs to store that music (or some representation thereof), and if it does that without the artist's permission, it's infringement.

So one option could be to get out of ContentID entirely and then forbid Google to go after her fans.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by asuffield on Friday January 23, 2015 @08:47PM (#8938486)
It seems fairly clear to me from the article that this is entirely her choice already. She has three options: sign the new agreement and continue receiving cash for videos including her content, drop out of the agreement and stop receiving cash but leave the videos up, or drop out of the agreement and take all the videos down. She has full control over this.
Re:What should I do about YouTube? by paulmd on Saturday January 24, 2015 @10:28AM (#8939795)
Nope. A SHA-256 cryptographic hash isn't a "version" of a file in any sense of the word. You couldn't (for example) run a binary hash of an executable, nor can you convert it into an executable file by compiling it or reversing the hash algorithm.

Perceptual hashes work the same way.

Re:What should I do about YouTube? by Kalium on Saturday January 24, 2015 @01:04AM (#8938952)
I think it should be noted that she has the same thing going on. She's idealistic in a way that just happens to be very convenient for her and her finances. What's convenient for others isn't a concern.

What's interesting is that she poses her doing this as morally superior to someone else doing this.