News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by HarryHirsch on Friday January 23, 2015 @02:44PM (#8936802)
Road safety is an admirable goal, but that's an issue that you tackle with liability law, car registration and inspection regulations, road users code &c. The DMCA is such a badly written piece of law that lends itself to overreach, and it doesn't need to be extended to yet another area.

Besides, people have been tuning their cars for 100 years now, you'd think that by now the police had some experience keeping the worst specimens of the public roadways.

Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by kw71 on Friday January 23, 2015 @02:54PM (#8936874)
We have computer-controlled braking and throttles now, and while I figure it's unlikely that someone will tinker with the brakes software (as long as it's not integrated into something he wants to tinker with) there has been a famous case where a factory throttle control has been alleged to be bad.

The emissions (and taxes in the countries where taxes are a function of emissions) aspects are more likely to be the justification of any repercussions against these activities.

Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by jordan0day on Friday January 23, 2015 @03:10PM (#8936958)
I don't really understand the emissions argument, though? If I'm trying to break the law (either tax law or emissions laws), why would copyright law (or laws around reverse engineering) deter me?
Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by MrDom on Friday January 23, 2015 @07:54PM (#8938354)
We have computer-controlled braking and throttles now

Couldn't the same case be made for doing your own mechanic work, though? We have braking, which is hydraulic and throttles which operate by wire. There's nothing preventing you from replacing the tried and true hydraulic brakes with something that runs on bluetooth. That would be just as dangerous as messing with the software of modern car brakes. More so, since one would hope modern car software has some failsafes built in[0].

[0]: they probably don't, but I know Sevcon does. Sevcon is a company that makes electric vehicle controllers for EV vehicles. They're popular with the DIY e-motorcycle crowd. Messing with the settings directly affects the power delivered to the motor.

Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by stolio on Friday January 23, 2015 @09:28PM (#8938597)
Pulling out your old throttle system is hard. It's self-protecting, the difficulty keeps the uninitiated from doing anything too stupid.

Copy/pasting code from the internet is easy, so it has to be made artificially difficult. We live in a world where people put their iPhones in microwaves because they heard it would charge the battery. We have to keep these people very far away from the internal workings of their cars.

Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by MrDom on Friday January 23, 2015 @11:07PM (#8938783)
Have you ever tried to program a controller? It's hard too. You need special hardware, special software and know how to connect them all up. It's not just copying and pasting code from the internet. It's sufficiently discouraging for those who think microwaves are wireless battery chargers. :)

If you're curious, you should poke around http://endless-sphere.com/forums/.

Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by stolio on Saturday January 24, 2015 @12:14AM (#8938890)
I appreciate the link, but at this point I'm not going to buy a car if I don't trust and like the engineers who built it. My "improvements" generally aren't :)

Even with needing special hardware and software I'm not happy about it the tinkering. Cars are too much: 3,500 lbs of metal going 40 mph with 10 gallons of gas in it is a lot to go wrong.

I hate DRM, I really do. And I think we should have kids programming Arduino's and Raspberry Pi's by junior high, but part of me thinks they should bury the computers so deep in the engine bay you have to pull the engine to get to 'em. It's just my opinion, but if you don't have a (relevant) PE license, minimum, you shouldn't be allowed to mess with ECU's in cars that go on public roads.

Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by vonmoltke on Friday January 23, 2015 @02:47PM (#8936825)
A solution to the road safety and emissions issues is to come up with a public standard for ECU software. Make adherence to that standard a requirement to pass the annual tests in states that have them. States that don't (I'm looking at you, Florida) have already stated indirectly that they don't really give a shit about these issues.
Re:It Should Not Be Illegal to Hack Your Own Car’s Computer by niels_olson on Friday January 23, 2015 @02:51PM (#8936842)
What about tuning an autonomous car? What if the autonomous car kills somebody? What if it wasn't your algorithm? You bought it off some guy? Is that a false sale? Who pays for the hospital bill?