Re:Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]
by vacri on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:40PM
(#8937460)
It's weird that you don't see the benefit of being effective while moving when your rebuttal includes 'run'. Not to mention that there are plenty of situations where stakes/hills/woods as a static defense don't apply - if you're attacking; if you're sieging; attacking a town, fighting in the streets; if you're not taking part in a large set-piece battle; so on and so forth. If you're part of a small patrol and encounter the enemy, you fight them then and there, no time to plant stakes or move the site of the battle.
Likewise, you need to be able to move around as the battle progresses. There's no point standing behind your stakes if the enemy you need to put pressure on is 200 yards away over a meadow. All the zen-like calmness in the world and impregnable field position isn't going to help you if the enemy doesn't come within range.
Re:Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]
by paulgerhardt on Friday January 23, 2015 @03:14PM
(#8936989)
"Stand and loose" is an ok strategy but "Ride and Loose" let the Mongols capture more territory in 25 years than the Romans did in 400.
Hardly the "only" strategy.
Re:Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]
by scott_s on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:17PM
(#8937323)
The Commanche were also particularly effective at it. The combination of their horse riding and archery skills made them more lethal than the US Army, until the revolver was invented. Before the revolver, firing on horseback was a non-starter because reloading was almost impossible; a Commanche could fire dozens of arrows in the time it took one reload. I read about this in the book "Empire of the Summer Moon" by S. C. Gwynne.
Re:Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]
by BashiBazouk on Friday January 23, 2015 @04:47PM
(#8937500)
Samurai as well. Very skilled horse archers.
Re:Lars Andersen: a new level of archery [video]
by romaniv on Friday January 23, 2015 @02:19PM
(#8936671)
While the notion that "stand and loose" was important in war seems sensible to me, the implication that mobility and shooting speed were irrelevant does not. Being able too shoot fast seems like an immensely useful skill when confronting a mass of enemies that move, have armor and actively try to avoid getting shot. More shots per minute would mean more chance to actually inflict damage.
Also, what about smaller confrontations that did not involve a wall of charging cavalry/footmen?
While the acrobatics is silly, what this guy is doing is impressive and indicate skills that could be applied more broadly.
As for hunting, that is extreme slowness, and perfect accuracy because you won't get a second shot, and if you move at all before loosing the animal moves too. Hunters wait.
So apart from firing in the saddle, archery was and is about stillness, accuracy and yes, in war, speed.
The guys able to put 30 arrows into the attacking targets at 50 paces will win the war, and the guys setting snares will fill the pot ;-)