Re:Elevator Saga – An elevator programming game
by SeoxyS on Friday January 23, 2015 @03:29AM
(#8933918)
Responding to GP; I think it's a tiny bit clearer with `== true`, but I don't feel particularly strongly about it. I wrote this code without caring too much about style and cleanliness.
However, I don't agree that the shortest code is always the cleanest. In JS for example, I've found that wrapping every conditional body in braces even if it's a single statement helps avoid bugs and clear out ambiguity.
Also, this code:
if (foo()) {
return true;
} else {
return false;
}
is not equivalent to return foo();
because foo() could return something that isn't boolean. The correct short version would be: return !!foo();
It's far less obvious what is going on here. That said, I'd probably go with: return foo() ? true : false;
Re:Elevator Saga – An elevator programming game
by JoeAltmaier on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:20AM
(#8933516)
Many languages are expressions (as opposed to statements) including C-like languages. I've always thought that 'return' itself was redundant. If a compound statement was defined to return the value of the final (executed) statement, then functional methods would get much simpler. And remove the need for the '?' operator for instance.
e.g.
int foo(int x) { bar(x,y); }
or x = {if (foo() > 9) true; else false; }
Re:Elevator Saga – An elevator programming game
by _lce0 on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:04PM
(#8935902)
I think one problem with statements-as-expression is that is not always evident which should be their result.
for instance:
bool r = if (test()) {
false;
} else {
true;
}
what r should be set to? true or false?I don't see the point of adding such complexity.. it's waaay more clear to be explicit
bool r = test();
if (r) {
false;
} else {
true;
}
or, if you intended the other way bool r;
if (test()) {
r = false;
} else {
r = true;
}
I guess that's why you need to be strictly correct, or highly opinionated, to design a language.
Re:Elevator Saga – An elevator programming game
by JoeAltmaier on Friday January 23, 2015 @02:06PM
(#8936595)
I'm missing your point I guess. All those are equivalent?
In C an assignment has the value of the RHS, so that doesn't change anything in these examples.
Re:Elevator Saga – An elevator programming game
by molo on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @01:23PM
(#8954695)
That is unnecessary verbosity. Try this instead:
bool r = !test();
Re:Elevator Saga – An elevator programming game
by thedufer on Friday January 23, 2015 @01:21AM
(#8933642)
Have you tried coffeescript? Your examples are pretty close to valid code that does what you want.
Also, I can never understand why people write ..
.. or things like extra parens on conditionals, or weird styles like: I strongly believe people write as they talk, and talk as they think; which not clearly translates linearly when what you write is code ;)