Is that really the ethos you see Apple emanating? Because I've always seen the opposite. One of the things that I thought coolest about Apple back when I was on Windows were the people who talked about installing Leopard on a Powerbook and having it still work perfectly. Ditto the iPhone now. In fact, the line I hear directly from Apple is "Because we have no physical controls, we're allowed to keep our 1st gen iPhones in line with our freshest models, so the iPhone will outlast many of the other phones its age." Certainly my iPod is showing no strain in its second year. I haven't even upgraded to 3.0 and it still feels great.
Plus, AAPL's "throw away and buy the shiny new one" ethos has kept the majority of users constantly updating their already new ipod/iphone/mac for quite some time, so this fragmentation might as well be yet another strong point on their evil marketing plot. "1st gen iphone? Sheesh, that's too old, go get a new one"