Re:Text-only video game shows how genre can be beautiful, in...
by djur on Thursday January 22, 2015 @09:33PM
(#8933115)
I don't think most members of the IF community would argue that IF is the only way to tell a story through a computer. It's just one particular approach with its own advantages and disadvantages.
And IF need not be pure text. Text with graphical accompaniment has been part of the genre almost since its inception, just like books can have illustrations.
Re:Text-only video game shows how genre can be beautiful, in...
by dfan on Friday January 23, 2015 @08:32AM
(#8934703)
No one in the IF world would claim that games "must be pure text".
Re:Text-only video game shows how genre can be beautiful, in...
by erikb on Friday January 23, 2015 @11:00AM
(#8935466)
Not literally, yes. But would you consider Shadowrun Returns or Faster Than Light a success for the IF world? I think most IF world people don't. And that's why I conclude that they have a very specific definition of what counts as IF and what doesn't. We could discuss about the details what exactly is part of IF and what isn't. But that's not the point anyway. The point is, that IF people can be proud because text heavy games are quite successful, but maybe they shouldn't think so purist.
Text is not a game. It's a feature. Depth is not a game. It's a feature. A puzzle or labyrinth is not a game. It's a feature. Make games by smartly combining (multiple!) features!