News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by soup10 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:26PM (#8926498)
tl;dr Human intelligence is special. Computer accomplishments like being good at chess is not real intelligence. In fact anything computers ever do is not real intelligence, because they aren't like us and possibly never will be because there is some divine truth and wisdom that only humans posses.

How many times do we have to hear these arguments to realize they are just hot air? Either computers are capable of intelligence, or they are not. The answer to that question depends entirely on how you define intelligence. If you define it as the set of things humans are capable of and computers are not, then the answer will always be no. But just like humans, computers learn and are taught new things every day, and as time goes on the set of things human's are uniquely capable of grows smaller and smaller.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by 21echoes on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:12PM (#8926684)
The article stands in direct contradiction to your supposed summary of it. To wit:

> Despite this long record of failure, AGI must be possible. And that is because of a deep property of the laws of physics, namely the universality of computation.

> [Turing] concluded that a computer program whose repertoire included all the distinctive attributes of the human brain — feelings, free will, consciousness and all — could be written. This astounding claim split the intellectual world into two camps, one insisting that AGI was none the less impossible, and the other that it was imminent. Both were mistaken.

etc etc etc. He literally spends more than 60% of the (very long) essay arguing against your "summary".

Anyway, a real tl;dr is right at the top of the page: "Expecting to create an AGI without first understanding in detail how it works is like expecting skyscrapers to learn to fly if we build them tall enough." and then the last sentence: "it is plausible that just a single idea stands between us and the breakthrough. But it will have to be one of the best ideas ever."

In other words, AGI is provably possible, but the author believes that we're going about it all wrong (behaviorist-inspired neural nets running on training sets, etc.) and need a philosophical (specifically: epistemological) breakthrough to move forward.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by deeviant on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:17PM (#8926928)
The last thing that AGI needs is more philosophical thinking. Philosophy and the Turing Test have done enough damage to the field.

Philosophers can not seem to comprehend how a mass of meat can create consciousness and take leaps to try to rule out the mass of meat, regardless of the fact that they all know that when bad things happen to said mass of meat bad things also happen to said consciousness.

The Turing Test could not have been a more wrong direction to define AGI. Looking like something does not make you that thing, and it did not at all address capability, just the appearance of capability.

Insight into intelligence will come slowly, and it will come from examining, categorizing, and eventually understanding the internal workings of the human brain.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by 21echoes on Thursday January 22, 2015 @04:07PM (#8931754)
This is such a short-sighted and close-minded view of philosophy, it boggles the mind..

> Philosophers can not seem to comprehend how a mass of meat can create consciousness and take leaps to try to rule out the mass of meat, regardless of the fact that they all know that when bad things happen to said mass of meat bad things also happen to said consciousness.

You seem to be referring to dualism, a philosophical idea that is largely discredited among philosophers since the early 1900's. Functionalism, emergentism, materialism, and all other leading serious philosophies of mind that implicate the brain were first formalized and studied by philosophers, not neuroscientists.

> The Turing Test could not have been a more wrong direction to define AGI. Looking like something does not make you that thing, and it did not at all address capability, just the appearance of capability.

And philosophers are among the most vocal critics of the Turing Test. The Turing Test was made by Turing, who was first and foremost a mathematician & logician, not a philosopher of mind.

> Insight into intelligence will come slowly, and it will come from examining, categorizing, and eventually understanding the internal workings of the human brain.

Which, of course, is what modern philosophers of mind do.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by deeviant on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @02:23AM (#8958580)
As I already stated, the primary rebuke against the Turing Test was the Chinese room. It was a proper response to a horrible idea.

Then what did philosophers do? Well they applied the Chinese Room argument to all of conciseness, a blunder even worse than the Turing Test.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by pron on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:38PM (#8927000)
> Philosophers can not seem to comprehend how a mass of meat can create consciousness and take leaps to try to rule out the mass of meat, regardless of the fact that they all know that when bad things happen to said mass of meat bad things also happen to said consciousness.

Neither can anyone else, so far.

> Insight into intelligence will come slowly, and it will come from examining, categorizing, and eventually understanding the internal workings of the human brain.

Insight -- yes. AI -- not so certain. Here's why: it's plausible that intelligence in the human mind emerges as a consequence of an intractable process. We might not be able to understand that intractable process. But suppose that instead of understanding it, we mimic it: we build a replica of the human brain, and it works! But this is not quite artificial intelligence but a replica of natural intelligence. This is not just a semantic difference: even if this mimicry works we may not be able to direct it in any way. For example, we won't necessarily be able to give this brain replica super-human intelligence, without, say, giving it a mental illness at the same time.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by deeviant on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:16PM (#8927131)
> Neither can anyone else, so far.

But most AIG researchers don't throw their hands up and say, "Oh damn, it's impossible (intractable), it's magic because we don't understand." Forgive me if I feel this a less-than-useful sentiment.

As far as the possibility of intelligence being intractable, what are the chances of this. Is it likely? If we don't even know what AIG entails, how would we possibly put odds on this? If we don't have the odds, what use is there is thinking about it? Should we stop researching AIG because of the possibility that it might be too much for us to handle?

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by pron on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:25PM (#8927170)
> But most AIG researchers don't throw their hands up and say, "Oh damn, it's impossible...

Neither does the author of the article.

> As far as the possibility of intelligence being intractable, what are the chances of this.

I think the odds are very good. Every known complex system -- the weather, for example, or an ant colony -- is intractable, let alone the human brain.

> Should we stop researching AIG because of the possibility that it might be too much for us to handle?

Intractability doesn't mean it's too much for us to handle. We can simulate intractable processes, and we do it all the time (that's how the weatherman knows if it's going to rain tomorrow), so of course it can be studied. The problem with intractable processes is not that they can't be artificially created, but they can't be artificially controlled (or predicted) beyond very short time frame. So it's very possible we could build an AGI, but won't know how to make it any smarter than us.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by throwmeunder on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:32PM (#8927540)
>So it's very possible we could build an AGI, but won't know how to make it any smarter than us.

Make it as smart as the smartest of us and then it'll figure out how to become smarter on its own. Then ask it to explain to us how we work.

Tongue in cheek but once almost-as-intelligent-as-a-human level is reached the next step is not that far fetched - quantity, multiple times faster than humans learning and we have progression on a different scale. Or we can always try mutating the thing to see what comes out - crude but worked at least once.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by pron on Thursday January 22, 2015 @07:29AM (#8928794)
> once almost-as-intelligent-as-a-human level is reached the next step is not that far fetched - quantity, multiple times faster than humans learning and we have progression on a different scale.

But this doesn't necessarily follow. The experience of a mind working at a higher speed will be a slowing down of time -- imagine what you'd do if time slowed down. The machine will not necessarily learn more (we might have a limit of how much we can learn), and will probably experience boredom and frustration (as everything around it will be slow) that might drive it crazy.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by ytturbed on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:42PM (#8927016)
I don't expect professional philosophers will contribute much either. But it's plausible that a philosophical advance (a new way of thinking) within an existing field such as computer science will lead to the breakthrough. Deutsch has claimed elsewhere that all great advances in science are like this. For example, Darwin's Theory of Evolution represented a fundamentally new mode of explanation.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by oppositereally on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:40PM (#8926543)
I think that misunderstands the article (a forgivable offense: it is very long).

tl;dr: AGI is possible, but we're going about it all wrong and won't create it until we philosophically understand it.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by IvyMike on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:43PM (#8926563)
Deutsch discounts the possibility that we create AGI the same way the universe did: as a sum of emergent behaviors honed by an evolutionary process. Nobody developing an AGI is going to code every behavior, line by line. They're going to code an infrastructure within which an AGI could work.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by thom on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:19PM (#8926711)
The interesting thing about this is that the AGI will probably have about as good an idea of how its brain works as we do. While I agree this is likely to be the way AGI comes about, I suspect it will impact its ability to improve itself. What are the ramifications of (let's say) human-level intelligence running on different hardware?
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by breuleux on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:45PM (#8927025)
Well, if AGI evolves from infrastructure that naturally fosters intelligence, then it is probable that most intelligence gains are actually a function of better infrastructure. This suggests that individual intelligences are actually dead ends: if a new, better infrastructure comes up, you can't just port an existing AGI to it because the whole of it is organized suboptimally: training a new AGI from scratch will always be faster than to try to improve the old one. It's similar to how new software projects can innovate more easily than existing ones because they don't have legacy burdens.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by ytturbed on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:17PM (#8926701)
>In fact anything computers ever do is not real intelligence

No, he doesn't say that. On the contrary he names the principle ('Universality of Computation'; see paragraph 4) which guarantees that computers are capable of true intelligence, since, if programmed correctly, they can simulate the behaviour of any physical object, including human brains.

>there is some divine truth and wisdom that only humans possess.

He also explicitly repudiates supernatural explanations (see para immediately before the one mentioning John Searle).

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by noiv on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:21PM (#8926716)
> is not real intelligence

Why is it so hard to remove our self from that equation? Why should intelligence be a skill only humans acquire? It is not only about machines: There is a constant stream of papers revealing animals are not that dumb as thought either. We survived recognizing we are not the center of the universe, may be we are also not alone on the top of the intelligence pyramid.

Latest edge question "What do you think about machines that think?" provides a good and very broad overview of many aspects. I go with George Church: "What do you care what other machines think?"

http://edge.org/responses/what-do-you-think-about-machines-t...

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by pesenti on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:54PM (#8926620)
Every time an AI system beats a human at a task that was previously thought hard (chess, jeopardy, face recognition, etc) many people immediately dismiss it as not reflecting real intelligence any longer.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:45PM (#8926804)
When that process is complete, and every tasks has been eliminated from those reflecting "real intelligence", we will be certain that we have created artificial intelligence by any measure that matters.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by java-man on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:46PM (#8926582)
Jeff Hawkins defines intelligence as the ability to predict. I think it's a good definition: it allows us to measure intelligence.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by thom on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:31PM (#8926754)
I've not read much about this definition, but it seems that a problem with focusing on the ability to predict is that to get useful work done, you have to reduce everything to a decision problem. You have an ideal fitness function, but how are you generating ideas, plans or theories to evaluate?

I personally prefer (although it's certainly less measurable) Ben Goertzel's definition - the ability to achieve complex goals in complex environments. It's still wishy-washy enough for people to write off any given achievement of AI though, I guess.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by chriskanan on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:36PM (#8926771)
The brain as a prediction and inference engine (the Bayesian brain) has been accepted by many in neuroscience. I think this article is novel because he rebels against this idea. I do think that many of the things that we consider intelligence are prediction, image recognition, speech comprehension, understanding other's theory of mind, and many games (e.g., chess).

I think Deutsch's argument is that there is also creativity (and creative reasoning) that is omitted from today's approaches to AI.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by biomimic on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:56PM (#8926633)
I think Steven Pinker had good takes on mimicking human cognition in his book, How the Mind Works along with describing Computational Theory of the Mind (CTM) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computational_theory_of_mind
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by ForHackernews on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:17PM (#8926926)