News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by jedberg on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:32PM (#8924595)
It's not the price of Windows that was keeping people from adopting Windows 8. It's the irrelevancy and the fact that corporations don't see the ROI. The time it would take to upgrade their company isn't worth the gains, which are minimal.

Unless Windows 10 proves to be a massive improvement in performance or usability, I suspect it's uptake will be just as anemic, free or not.

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by iza on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:42PM (#8924662)
What prevented companies from updating was the bastardized UI requiring retraining and extra IT support. I don't think Windows 10 necessarily needs a huge improvement. Companies will either update when they upgrade the physical computers and the new ones happen to come with Windows 10, or when some crucial piece of software drops support for 7. They won't actively avoid 10 or downgrade like some did for 8.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by colechristensen on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:49PM (#8925195)
All Windows 10 needs is the option to make the UI look and behave the same as Windows 95 to 7. Do that, and the enterprise world will adopt it.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by Someone1234 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @03:43PM (#8925601)
The upgrade isn't "free" for most companies, kinda.

If they're a small business and use OEM installed copies of Windows and those OEM copies are Pro or lower then, yes, they get a free upgrade.

If it comes with Enterprise OEM they won't get the upgrade, and if they are on a volume licence (which most companies, even medium sized are) then they won't get a free upgrade and will instead need Software Assurance (subscription upgrades).

Many companies upgrade because of non-obvious benefits, namely how newer versions of Windows ineract with Active Directory, WDS, WUS, and similar. Every version of Windows comes with new and sometimes impressive enterprise features that consumers just rarely notice.

For example, go here[0] and look at the Enterprise column. It is these types of things that are what gets enterprise excited, not how pretty alt-tab looks or if it has Cortana.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_8_editions

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by fit2rule on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:50PM (#8925210)
I haven't used Windows in 10+ years, so I've got some questions for those who are smarter than me on the subject of Windows:

Does it come with package management yet? Can I easily avoid DLL hell these days? Can I add my own local repository and use it to maintain a fleet of workstations, making sure they always have the same configuration no matter what?

Is it easily possible to connect to a Windows machine and administer it from a command line/scripting environment? Can I disable the GUI and use Windows without tying up resources for unneeded functionality - i.e. no graphics card required?

Is all of this onboard, or does some/most of it require the involvement of a 3rd-party add-on? If its not onboard, can I validate that 3rd-party with signed keys? Is there an onboard key agent that will make this possible?

Is there an easy way to get a compiler onboard without requiring registration and so on, or does it ship with development tools already set up and configured? Are these tools usable without requiring GUI involvement - i.e. remotely?

These are earnest questions, I honestly don't know. If the majority of the answers are in the affirmative, then I'll give Windows 10 a try - it would make a nice change from what I've gotten used to with my Linux machine.

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by Amezarak on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @03:07PM (#8925354)
> Does it come with package management yet?

No. There is the Windows Store (all or most Metro apps, GUI) and things like NuGet for Visual Studio, but that's not what you're looking for. There are third-party solutions.

[EDIT: See sibling comments; W10 adds one.]

> Can I easily avoid DLL hell these days?

DLL Hell is no longer a concern. It's not a matter of avoiding it, it won't happen except perhaps in very unusual edge cases I'm not familiar with.

> Can I add my own local repository and use it to maintain a fleet of workstations, making sure they always have the same configuration no matter what?

You can do this. This is one reason Windows is so big in enterprise.

> Is it easily possible to connect to a Windows machine and administer it from a command line/scripting environment?

Yes.

> Can I disable the GUI and use Windows without tying up resources for unneeded functionality - i.e. no graphics card required?

In Server 2012 onwards, the GUI is optional.

> If its not onboard, can I validate that 3rd-party with signed keys? Is there an onboard key agent that will make this possible?

I am not 100% on what you want, but yes, Windows executables are commonly signed and that is integrated with the OS.

> Is there an easy way to get a compiler onboard without requiring registration and so on, or does it ship with development tools already set up and configured?

Windows does not ship with a compiler or other developer tools installed. You can install Visual Studio 2013 Community Edition, which has all the features of Professional Edition, for free and without registration (afaik - I'm doing it right now, so if I'm wrong, I'll edit). You can of course install all the free-software development tools you want. Most tools support Windows reasonably well.

> Are these tools usable without requiring GUI involvement - i.e. remotely?

Yes, although most people don't do so. I've only fiddled around. I've heard that manually fiddling with msbuild is actually more pleasant than using the GUI.

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by Locke1689 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @03:38PM (#8925571)
>You can install Visual Studio 2013 Community Edition,

If you prefer to use the compiler and build system at the command line and you're only interested in managed development (i.e., C#), you can download the Microsoft Build tools package[1], which contains the compilers and MSBuild for headless development.

[1] http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=4493...

>> Are these tools usable without requiring GUI involvement - i.e. remotely?

Yes, I do most of my building on the command line. Editing, of course, is in VS, but I've also had fine success with Vim.

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by Someone1234 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @03:47PM (#8925641)
This is completely pedantic and adds nothing to the discussion, but 2008 R2 added Core Mode, rather than 2012. 2012 continues it however.

Otherwise your post is great.

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by fit2rule on Thursday January 22, 2015 @02:40AM (#8928025)
Thanks for taking the time to reply - it seems that Windows is not quite caught up with the usability/experience that I've become accustomed to with Linux after 15+ years. I might take some time to learn about Windows 10 when its released, but it appears that it may not be worth the hassle ... I'm a Linux/embedded developer and have become quite accustomed to the serviceability of Linux. I think, based on your response, I would probably end up just getting frustrated with Windows.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by greggyb on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @03:01PM (#8925307)
I can answer a few:

Package management: Yes[0]

DLLs: Do not know

Local Repository: Seems to be a part of package management based on things I've seen

Command line/scripting: Powershell has been around for a while now and is quite good, but a very different idiom than UNIX shell[1].

Disable GUI: Don't believe so, but can't say for sure

Onboard: The above is all native

Easy compiler: unsure.

[0]http://www.howtogeek.com/200334/windows-10-includes-a-linux-...

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_PowerShell

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by rasz_pl on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @04:13PM (#8925813)
>Can I easily avoid DLL hell these days?

DLL hell was replaced by >20GB WinSxS directory. Every version of every single DLL, regardless if you ever used or will use one. Stored forever, with no usage stats, no mechanism of trimming, no archive option for never used ones. Introduced just in time to fill ~$40 worth of SSD with data that will NEVER EVER be read again.

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by mavhc on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:55PM (#8925255)
> Does it come with package management yet?

Not really

> Can I easily avoid DLL hell these days?

Yes, it just stores every version on the drive, seems to work

> Can I add my own local repository and use it to maintain a fleet of workstations, making sure they always have the same configuration no matter what?

For free? not easily.

> Is it easily possible to connect to a Windows machine and administer it from a command line/scripting environment?

Powershell does a lot more on this front

> Can I disable the GUI and use Windows without tying up resources for unneeded functionality - i.e. no graphics card required?

Considering Windows Server Core still has a GUI? no.

> does it ship with development tools already set up and configured?

No

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by fit2rule on Thursday January 22, 2015 @02:37AM (#8928022)
Thanks - so it seems Windows is not competitive with my 15+ years of experience with Linux. I would have thought that would have changed by now, but I guess its just different.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by epochwolf on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:08PM (#8924883)
I would have upgraded several of my machines to Windows 8 if it wasn't for the price. I already have a bunch of Windows 7 licenses.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by abandonliberty on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:50PM (#8925213)
I got an 8 upgrade when offered it for 20$. It was worth the price.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by cwyers on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:09PM (#8924901)
Microsoft has always had seperate enterprise and consumer pricing for Windows. This is an announcement about consumer pricing. So... consumer pricing won't affect enterprise adoption. We already knew that, though.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by bad_user on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:19PM (#8924976)
Users in general don't upgrade unless forced, because non-technical folks are conservative. All of Microsoft's competition have encouraged (free) updates in one way or another, with much less regard towards backwards compatibility. This also creates expectations for developers, assuming that a majority will upgrade in a timely manner, therefore users feel compelled to upgrade otherwise their favorite apps may stop being supported for their current OS.

Microsoft's biggest enemy is the old Microsoft that took years to update Windows XP and IExplorer 6. And then Vista happened, which brought no improvements, except a flawed and annoying security model, bloat and instability. And do I even need to rant on 8.0? So it's no wonder that users lost their appetite for updates.

However, I believe there is serious room for improvement in how we use our computers, especially our PCs. However that line on a single OS for all devices doesn't sound good to me, because there are fundamental differences between the devices in question and I hope that Microsoft will do more than marketing gimmicks and interfaces meant for tablets being shown on large screens that have keyboards.

Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by yuhong on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:48PM (#8925191)
Vista bought no improvements? BTW, I think always notify for UAC is a better idea anyway.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by talmand on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @04:54PM (#8926035)
If the negatives outweigh the positives, would there be improvements?
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by overgard on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:09PM (#8926422)
I think most companies like to be up to date as long as the move is at least lateral. I think the problem with windows 8 was that it was largely seen as a downgrade. Nobody really liked the new features or wanted them. If Windows 10 isn't worse than Windows 7, I think people will upgrade.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by cheshire137 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @04:21PM (#8925859)
The price is what was keeping me from upgrading my personal PC running Windows 7.
Re:Windows 10 upgrade to be 'free' for one year by moskie on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:19PM (#8924978)
Even if price wasn't the main problem that prevented adoption, it's the problem with the easiest and most obvious solution: make it free. So it's a good thing they addressed it.