News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by dkopi on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:49AM (#8922817)
I think that something inherent but generally unacknowledged is how Socialism and Anti capitalist ideologies rob creativity of any and all usefulness. Exploring ideas for the sake of solving real world problems, making people's lives better, is a wonderful and incomparable thing.
Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by jacquesm on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:03AM (#8922863)
> I think that something inherent but generally unacknowledged is how Socialism and Anti capitalist ideologies rob creativity of any and all usefulness.

Socialism?

I think you meant 'communism' as practiced by those countries that have hi-jacked an otherwise pretty good idea to serve the interests of a select few fat cats.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by happyscrappy on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:51AM (#8923029)
So far all that has worked is Socialism with Capitalist ideologies. Is there some example of Socialism and Anti-Capitalist ideologies that has worked?
Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by forgottenpass on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @10:07AM (#8923349)
I think you're reading too much into the parent poster. It's possible to point out negative properties of something without advocating for a radical shift, or any shift.

Business incentives stifle creativity; even in creative products. It may wax and wane depending on context, but it's a pretty uncontroversial idea. From the high end of LA creativity-through-the-sausage-machine film and tv, all the way through to the low end, where nobody wants to attend my one man show.

But the parent poster used the HN tigger word "capitalism" when discussing the idea, so lets down-vote the shit out of him! /s

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by chriscool on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:14AM (#8922897)
People working on open source projects often solve real problems and make other people's life better, yet some of them consider themselves anti-capitalist or even socialist.
Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by dkopi on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:19AM (#8922914)
Many successful open source projects have a corporate backing to them, driving resources and energy into them.

Open source isn't anti capitalist. It's capitalism at it's best form. People join at their own free will, the rule of contracts (open source licensing) are strictly enforced, and there are lots of ways people can profit from open source.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by skidoo on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @07:51AM (#8922823)
Do that without expecting financial reward, and your soapbox would hold some meaning. "Usefulness" is not synonymous for monetization. Making the world better is not synonymous for making a few people that much richer.
Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by dkopi on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:14AM (#8922899)
That's not how Human nature works. The world is filled with failed experiments of "Just do good without expecting anything in return". "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need" has failed utterly, at every scale. Be it the soviet union, or small bankrupt "kibbutzim" in Israel.

Capitalism is much more than "expecting a financial reward". It's a complex system of signals which let producers determine what is the most valuable and efficient use for their resources.

What Should I build in my basement? A sous vide cooker? A drone with a camera? A computer game or a new social network? Capitalism and profit give the correct signals - what is it that the market demands. What do people truly feel they need?

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by jeremysmyth on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:22AM (#8922928)
Agree with everything you say, but would like to comment on this: Capitalism and profit give the correct signals - what is it that the market demands. What do people truly feel they need?

Art is the big gap here. Few could argue successfully that the world is not a better place for the creations of JS Bach, Kafka, Keats, Van Gogh, yet these people did not make their fortune from their life's passion and work. Only after their death were they appreciated for what they did in their figurative basements.

Capitalism provides one set of signals, an overpoweringly large one at that, but it does not provide a complete picture of value to humanity.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by lmm on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:07AM (#8923096)
> Art is the big gap here. Few could argue successfully that the world is not a better place for the creations of JS Bach, Kafka, Keats, Van Gogh, yet these people did not make their fortune from their life's passion and work. Only after their death were they appreciated for what they did in their figurative basements.

You're taking the exceptions (and actually Bach earnt quite well from music). Van Gogh was almost unique among his painting contemporaries, partly because his paintings were, by the standards of the time, weird (I suspect this applies to Kafka as well). And what vindicates him now is an ultimately capitalist consideration - his works are popular, people pay for copies of them. Nowadays there are capitalistic art speculators who will buy the work of underappreciated artists if they like it themselves - see the recent https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8829277 - which would solve that problem.

As for Kafka, he had a famously... weird approach to his work. IIRC he wanted his works destroyed; it's only the capitalism of his descendants that means we're able to appreciate them.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by ad_hominem on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:23AM (#8923165)
Art isn't the only place where people can be ahead of their time. Xerox PARC had a lot of good ideas, for example, but were only appreciated after some folks reappropriated them.

Gov't incentives meanwhile often create unintended effects. For example, incentivizing investment in the arts leading to rich people creating their own private museums, often inaccessible to the public, and using them as convenient funnels for tax deductions while still enriching themselves.[1]

[1]: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/11/business/art-collectors-ga...

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by im2w1l on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:35AM (#8923223)
Ok I'll try. All these people you mention are long-dead white men you are 'supposed' to like because it gives you social status. If they didn't exist there would probably be others you should like to give you signal how cultivated you are. You are forced to partake in their creations in school because of some mistaken cargo cult thinking "successful people like these artists so if force every to read/listen to/look at their creations they will be successful too!"

Contemporary pop art, on the other hand, entertains huge masses of people, gives them pleasure and delight, and makes their days happier.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by xerophyte12932 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:44AM (#8923006)
I think economic theory explains that case as well. Simply put, the value of "making art" was worth more to those artists than the value of whatever money they could have made doing other things. So of course, they weren't trying to satisfy some latent global need of art, they were just doing what they preferred.

Just as a farmer is not trying to satisfy the world's demand for food, monitoring which crop is most needed. All the farmer does is he prefers a certain amount of money over a certain amount of labour and grows crops that maximize that amount of money. The world signals their demand by price.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by barrkel on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:51AM (#8923026)
Beware of economic theory's ability to tell stories. It's a similar danger to evolutionary biology.

It's also at risk of the Is/Ought problem; the stories are not justifications.