Re:Working at Netflix
by jandrewrogers on Tuesday January 20, 2015 @04:30PM
(#8919746)
Yes. It is one of the few companies I've worked at where I saw substandard engineers get fired for being substandard. At most companies, they just shuffle substandard engineers around into a role where they won't cause too much damage.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I assume that also means you see engineers who are not substandard get fired for being substandard?
I don't think it's hard to imagine a great developer performing poorly because either the role or company is a poor fit.
In that situation, they are still "substandard". Ideally there would be some mentoring process that happens to try and get the employee on the right track. And a good recruiting process should minimize the number of employees who are a bad fit for whatever reason so this doesn't happen often. But at the end of the day, it really isn't good for the employee or employer to continue a relationship which isn't fruitful.
Indeed I would agree with this, I just thought the comment I replied to was disingenuous to only mention substandard engineers getting fired, when it really is engineers who are underperforming getting fired.
It just makes it seem as though getting fired implies you are a bad engineer, and not getting fired means you are somehow better than those who got fired.
Essentially it's a culture of elitism. Reminds me of Ivy League. It can work, but it's hard to scale and in my experience it's very hard to avoid a monoculture.
How diverse is the population of engineers at Netflix compared to other public tech companies at a similar stage?
A high-performing culture that emphasizes mentorship is better IMO.
It drives off a reasonable number of high-performing people as well, though obviously not all. One of the problems systems like stack ranking have encountered is that some proportion of people who are really good and not the intended target of the system end up very stressed out by it. Varying reasons: some people underestimate their own skills, some are worried about the system's false-positive rate, some are stressed out by worries about coworkers being fired even if not worried about their own job, etc.