What do you think happens when the two are rewarded equally, but the latter can be done much more frequently per unit of time?
Heck, even if the site was only for "novel" questions, according to your logic, only the most important unanswered question should be visible, until it is answered. Otherwise people might be incentivized to answer the second most important question instead.
I don't think they're mutually exclusive - there are multiple reward structures for multiple types of players. Both should be encouraged.
Further, there's the question of how much effort the questioner should be expected to put in. In a great many technical question fora, the experience is that many noobs make no attempt to search out answers.
So, yes. Internet points.
I'm not suggesting we leave obviously terrible questions open, it's the borderline posts that get me. Interesting questions which may not have a black and white answer, but would still encourage discussion/opinions which would be useful to people down the road. I know "it's not a discussion site", but sometimes there are gray areas and it's useful to have the opinions of experts on the pros and cons of certain approaches/technologies/whatever.
I suspect that SOs answer to your need is "Go use a different site". At some point, that becomes a reasonable answer.
I've some sympathy for that.