My complaint is that in most cases people are comparing average Science Fiction to the best of Classical Literature, but this tells you nothing about the best of Science Fiction.
Sure the average Science Fiction novel isn't as good as the best classical literature. But that's not the implication of the original comment. The implication is that Science Fiction is inferior--it's meant for entertainment, not capable of holding up to serious literature. Science Fiction is merely enjoyable, not sublime.
I'm not even sure it's that. I mean, what "genre" is "non genre" fiction? If "literate" fiction is just "anything with no specific genre" then that isn't saying much. And a lot of the classification of works into the category of "literate fiction" is post-hoc rationalization anyway.
This is like complaining that music from the 80s is so much better than music from today because you've cherry picked a few dozen gems from an entire decade.
[1] http://articles.latimes.com/2008/jul/27/entertainment/ca-cha...