News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by rhino369 on Monday January 19, 2015 @02:33PM (#8913587)
It is a misconception that the NSA is an anti-terrorism agency.

It is a general signal intelligence agency. It's job is the gather as much foreign intelligence as possible. And that sure includes:Like tracking the intricacies of various global markets, cultural movements, politicians, judges, activists and other influencers in society. Like basically an opportunity to see everybody at the table's cards (including your friends) in order to maximize power?

Where you go wrong is assuming that means they have some dastardly plan to subvert global democracy.

The government just really wants good intel. They want to know if Russian sanctions are working. They want to know if N. Korea is really just bullshiting or do they mean it. They want to know how much longer with Germany prop up Southern Europe. They want to know if Cuba is serious about opening up trade. They want to know if some French scientist is about to develop software that beats US electronic warfare defenses on their AEGIS destroyers.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by flycaliguy on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:25PM (#8914188)
Great response, thank you. You're right, it's hard during this current media push to remember that these organizations aren't just fighting terror. I suppose that is the easiest way to market them to keep the public from getting to concerned over it.

What if they are using the intel they are gathering in order to influence the public's opinion as effectively as possible? It's that sort of power consolidation that worries me and makes me question when an allegiance to the democratic nation that created them starts to fade away.

How does a free nation effectively control an intelligence agency like this to prevent it from slowly usurping all the seats of power? It seems to me that with the expanding technological capabilities of our modern age, we are feeding our guard dog a new super food and it's going to bite our neck if we try to slow down the input and tighten it's leash.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by rhino369 on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:16PM (#8914476)
It's possible, but there is no indication that the US security agencies "go rouge." The NSA might be stretching the 4th Amendment but it does so at the command of the President and it does within the bounds of the law.

When Obama had the CIA kill a US citizen, they wrote a legal memo about it.

The rule of law is still worshiped in the US.

It helps that the leadership of these agencies are political appointees and then rank and file are just regular bureaucrats.

The guys at the NSA aren't some secret cabal. It's the nerdy dood you play Settles of Caatan with at a game club in DC.

I also think controlling public opinion is a lot harder than you are imagining. Even in N. Korea the people generally know their country is bullshiting them.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by flycaliguy on Monday January 19, 2015 @07:51PM (#8914919)
I hope you are right. Ultimately I'm not opposed to American intelligence agencies. I'm aware that there are big threats beyond terrorism and it's important for us to have the best team with the best resources. If things escalate with China for example I'm willing to accept that sacrifices will have to be made to our concept of privacy as a wartime measure. If we have to pull pages out of Art of War to win this thing then I guess that's that.

I just worry that they have in fact gone rouge and have lost track of their real duty. Snowden's critique of citizen surveillance aside, his critique of America's ability to protect ourselves from China after crippling our nation's encryption efforts is what really bothers me. I'm worried that the agency, in an attempt to tighten it's grip on the western world's communication, is missing the important window to instead begin locking things down. They are missing our chance to get our corporations, institutions and infrastructure encrypted properly to protect civilians from cyberwar fallout. Protecting us from a modern war modelled in part on America's WWII strategic bombing campaign of German civilians in an era when we no longer have the geographical advantage of two oceans keeping us safe.

I think they got a taste of the power that comes with total information (not unlike the advertising world is with leaders like Zuckerburg [but thats another post...]) and are not willing to give it up and smarten up.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by LLWM on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:32PM (#8914241)
>What if they are using the intel they are gathering in order to influence the public's opinion as effectively as possible?

Then they're even more incompetent than any of us could have ever imagined.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by flycaliguy on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:06PM (#8914418)
Really? Because it seems to me like they are chugging along just fine. They have plenty of wiggle room unlike real adversaries like Snowden. If they've seen a dip in public support I'm sure short and long term projections have it not only solved but completely countered. They may never convince the HN crowd but the HN crowd doesn't need to be convinced.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by LLWM on Tuesday January 20, 2015 @05:15PM (#8920025)
Whether this is "good enough" for them to keep doing what they do wasn't the question. The question was whether they were doing their best to influence public opinion.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by TheCraiggers on Monday January 19, 2015 @03:05PM (#8913743)
Sure, but all that info is power. I understand why the US government wants power over other states, as distasteful as it is.

However, power corrupts, and I don't feel the government needs additional power over its own people. And I especially don't feel that a specific department needs power over people that just so happen to be politicians that might someday oppose that department.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by spammyusername on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:15PM (#8914116)
How would you know what use the information is being put to?
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by rhino369 on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:21PM (#8914495)
How do you know what the military is being put to? Any government power can be misused. Foreign intelligence isn't particularly dangerous.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by spammyusername on Monday January 19, 2015 @07:11PM (#8914826)
Foreign intelligence is used to interrogate/arrest/kill people. Only powers that are granted can be misused, we as citizens can take anything we want away from the government.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by LLWM on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:30PM (#8914220)
You don't. You elect people to represent you, they get told what use the information is being put to, and they make decisions accordingly.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by flycaliguy on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:48PM (#8914323)
What if they are lying to the officials? Or what if they have information on the officials? What if they don't have information on the officials but the officials have been convinced that they probably do?
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by LLWM on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:49PM (#8914330)
What if the officials are mind-controlled by alien slugs? What if the NSA is actually a terminator skynet sent back from the future?

There are lots of scenarios in which we're screwed and can't do anything about it. That's life.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by spammyusername on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:14PM (#8914460)
This is pure ignorance. No one who falls into the trap of thinking like this will ever contribute anything useful to society.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by LLWM on Tuesday January 20, 2015 @05:15PM (#8920030)
I would say that the statement easily disproven by a single counterexample is more ignorant, but suit yourself.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by flycaliguy on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:10PM (#8914440)
I'm no expert on logical fallacies but I think your response here is one of them.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by LLWM on Tuesday January 20, 2015 @05:16PM (#8920032)
I am an expert, and it's not. How do you like them arguments from authority?