Re:Undeveloped Film from a Soldier in WWII Discovered and Pr...
by anigbrowl on Saturday January 17, 2015 @09:24PM
(#8906365)
Undeveloped negatives are considered tangible for legal purposes, and the creation of the negative has been considered the primary work of authorship almost cince the inception of photography:
See Burrow-Giles Lithographic company v. Sarony, 111 US 53 - Supreme Court 1884, quoting Nottage v. Jackson, 11 QBD 627, High court 1883:
Brett, M.R., said, in regard to who was the author: "The nearest I can come to, is that it is the person who effectively is as near as he can be, the cause of the picture which is produced, that is, the person who has superintended the arrangement, who has actually formed the picture by putting the persons in position, and arranging the place where the people are to be — the man who is the effective cause of that."
Lord Justice Cotton said: "In my opinion, `author' involves originating, making, producing, as the inventive or master mind, the thing which is to be protected, whether it be a drawing, or a painting, or a photograph;" and Lord Justice Bowen says that photography is to be treated for the purposes of the act as an art, and the author is the man who really represents, creates, or gives effect to the idea, fancy, or imagination.
See Burrow-Giles Lithographic company v. Sarony, 111 US 53 - Supreme Court 1884, quoting Nottage v. Jackson, 11 QBD 627, High court 1883:
Brett, M.R., said, in regard to who was the author: "The nearest I can come to, is that it is the person who effectively is as near as he can be, the cause of the picture which is produced, that is, the person who has superintended the arrangement, who has actually formed the picture by putting the persons in position, and arranging the place where the people are to be — the man who is the effective cause of that."
Lord Justice Cotton said: "In my opinion, `author' involves originating, making, producing, as the inventive or master mind, the thing which is to be protected, whether it be a drawing, or a painting, or a photograph;" and Lord Justice Bowen says that photography is to be treated for the purposes of the act as an art, and the author is the man who really represents, creates, or gives effect to the idea, fancy, or imagination.
https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=177944096715959...