The comparison between algorithms and god is particularly egregious. If you don't understand god, it's because god doesn't exist. If you don't understand algorithms, it's because you haven't bothered to educate yourself (which is not an option for everyone, but the author is writing on the topic for a national magazine, so it isn't an unreasonable expectation.)
If, for a more technical audience, we replace "algorithm" with "ranking heuristic", then I think the religious comparison makes more sense. All of the "algorithms" that he references in the article are of this form, and the comments do not apply to more generalized algorithms; nobody is going to claim that "the QuickSort God is a fast sorting God" (though that does have a certain poetry).
Really, though, these heuristics and people's reaction to them harks back to earlier roots than religion in the modern sense; things like shamanism and magic (or "cargo-cult science"): the leap from "there are more birds in the sky before it rains" to "you there -- go into the forest to scare some birds, we need rain".
I think the mainstream use of the term "algorithm" (or nearly any buzzword) is at the mercy of myriad competing forces seeking to impose their interpreation on the phrase. At least one of those forces is marketing, which has incentive to offer parapharsed, sugar-coated snippets of what something is. This plays on a common aspect of human nature, which is to feel more secure in a situation in which one feels confident that things are accounted for. There are remarkable similarities in what priests, scryers, prophets, and oracles once did, and what, presently, the media, marketers, investors, fans, geeks philosophically abstracting from their technical work, and advocates of theories do-- namely, a presentation of truth from a limited set of the inititated to the mass public.
While it is true that algorithms have their place, it is also true that much of what is said about "algorithms" is part aggrandization, part embellishment, part over-simplifcation by marketers, media, non-technical users, or technical users who have a divergent system of beliefs, and invest much thought and effort into a potential future which may or may not occur, and which is not directly related to their technical work (e.g. technological singularity, etc.).
It's always good to (in theory) maintain perspective on such things, and not get carried away by an over-application of a singular idea.
Check out this section from Caltech's machine learning lectures about neural networks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ih5Mr93E-2c&hd=1#t=63m25s
"...sorry, we denied credit because lambda is less than 0.5. The fact that you are not able to interpret what happens in machine learning is very, very common."
We understand in principle what any given neural net is doing, but our lack of understanding of the specifics makes it impossible to trust them for anything interesting. We can't tell when they might fail.
For this reason a lot of people are busy solving problems that "machine learning" might one day handle, but we are doing it with relatively conventional algorithms that fall outside the "machine learning" envelope because the areas we work in (computer assisted surgery, say) aren't amenable to the application of things we don't understand.
To go back to his comparison with god: the incomprehensibility of gods is generally considered a feature by religious people. The incomprehensibility of machine learning algorithms is unquestionably a bug to those of us who have hard problems that need to be solved reliably.
Most of the algorithms you use in everyday life are not machine learning algorithms (and certainly not neural nets) for precisely this reason.
> the incomprehensibility of gods is generally considered a feature by religious people.
I'm not sure how you reach that conclusion. It's hard to generalize about "religious people" or even "religions" because they are so varied. I might point to the book of Job in the Christian Bible as evidence that the inscrutable nature of God (or the universe, if you prefer) is considered frustrating and tragic enough that scripture takes pains to attempt to explain it. In fact, there's an entire branch of theology [0] that tries to address this shortcoming.
> Most of the algorithms you use in everyday life are not machine learning algorithms
Is that true? My understanding is that almost all modern web services with vast data (Facebook, Google, Netflix) make at least some use of machine learning algorithms.
Sounds like we're making 'people 2.0'.
"I spend a lot of my time designing and tweaking Gods." sounds like the first line to a good Charlie Stross short story.
> Here’s an exercise: The next time you see someone talking about algorithms, replace the term with “God” and ask yourself if the sense changes any.
This comes immediately after a paragraph that lists four instances of people saying things about "algorithms" ... not one of which would have meant the same thing if it had said "God" instead.
Most of the recent occasions when I have used the word "algorithm" it's been in contexts like "We can probably come up with an algorithm to distinguish this case from that case" and "I spend a lot of my time designing and tweaking algorithms". Replacing "algorithm" with "God" doesn't make much sense there, either.
I suppose the author isn't really thinking about people who actually work with algorithms every day, but about the general public. I would hazard a guess that at least 75% of the general public have no idea what "algorithm" even means, are not familiar with (e.g.) the fact that Google's search engine is (kinda) executing one, and as a consequence don't have an attitude to "algorithms" that remotely resembles that of religious people towards their gods.
The sentence I quoted seems like the kind of thing people say to sound clever and insightful, without actually paying too much attention to whether it makes any sense.
There are (I think) some good points in the article, but having such overblown bullshit so prominent so early in it really doesn't encourage me to read it with the care the author presumably thinks it deserves.