Re:Elon Musk donates $10M to keep AI beneficial
by nbouscal on Thursday January 15, 2015 @11:38AM
(#8893467)
And the reason the argument is absurd is that of course the room doesn't understand Chinese; it's a lookup table! No Chinese speaker interacting with the Chinese room for any reasonable period of time would think it held a Chinese speaker, because all it accepts are questions, and it answers the same question the same way every time. Of course, Searle would say that the set of rules in the room is defined to be such that a Chinese person would think they were interacting with a Chinese speaker, but the very setup of the system prevents this from being possible. The thought experiment is fundamentally incoherent.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Elon Musk donates $10M to keep AI beneficial
by ajuc on Thursday January 15, 2015 @01:28PM
(#8894342)
I assumed the system has rewritable memory to remember previous questions, and the lookup is (all previous questions) -> next answer.
With such setup (require infinite memory) the system is Turing-complete of course.
If it works as you described it can't even answer "what was my n-th last question".