News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by dj-wonk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @10:19PM (#8890717)
From Andrew Sorkins' commentary on: http://dealbook.nytimes.com//2013/10/21/economic-theory-via-...

> [Ray Dalio] dispenses with the way economists have long taught economics in school, and instead explains the economy as if it were a “machine” that he believes is much easier to understand and predict.

"Dispenses", really? Dalio is no small force [1], but his thoughts and models are, in some sense, just "another" model to add to the mix.

[1]: http://www.economist.com/node/21549968

Here, my point is not to support or detract from Dalio's model. My point is simply that many people (and many journalists) don't seem to get what models are, at their core. They are tools.

Yes, sometimes traditional economic models get "too much" credit and mindshare. I like seeing alternative models. After taking a look at Dalio's snappy presentation, connecting almost everything with a nice explanation, I really miss an academic presentation, with equations. (I'm not saying Dalio doesn't have them -- Bridgewater Associates certainly does.)

Both in the case of this presentation and in many mainstream accounts, the language commonly used in economic models sometimes lulls readers/listeners/viewers into conflating the model with reality. Don't let it. The world is complicated. If you want to force a complicated world into a simple model, you can, with varying results.

Here is my central point. Everyone, including all flavors of economists and Dalio himself, are peddling models. Don't let their claims of being "simple" and "mechanical" distract you. (Some people claim the opposite, e.g. "my complex model is the most realistic".) People will accentuate any aspect of their model. Like any good salesperson or marketer, they will find the words that engender trust.

(In modeling-speak, modelers often seek to build models that their audience will find intuitive. Models that are too non-intuitive, in their assumptions at least, sometimes get quickly discarded. Models with intuitive low-level behavior and non-intuitive higher-level behavior often garner a lot of attention, because they are deemed to be believable but surprising.)

What makes a good model? That's a long conversation. For now, I'll just say this: use some model(s) that are useful for your situation. It is obvious, but you'd be amazed how few people take this advice to heart. Perhaps they want the "best" model, which is akin to asking for the "best" car. In practice, many people go with the most familiar model, though many don't like to admit it.

I'm not saying models are bad. I am saying two main things:

1. If you are using numbers (even rough ones) and seriously think that you aren't using a model, you are fooling yourself. I'll give three examples where people pretend that they aren't using a model:

1A. If you are shooting from the hip, then you are using an unspecified, perhaps instinctual, probably non-repeatable, model.

1B. If you are "just doing the numbers" then your choice of what numbers to include is your model.

1C. If you are doing "theory-free" data mining, then you are still relying on some technique(s) to surface certain patterns. Ok, so you might not be using a specified model (such as linear regression with particular variables), but how did you select your variables? If you are using a SVM, what kernel are you using? If you are using a NN, how many layers and what configuration? These are still assumptions. Your choice of technique (and preference for bias vs. variance) will shape what patterns you find.

2. Relying on too few models is foolish.

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by cbd1984 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @11:53PM (#8890944)
I don't understand how this video represents a departure from standard macroeconomic thinking. He presents the business cycle, with a boom as an inflationary period and a bust as a deflationary one leading into recessions, the idea of credit creating debt which can be an asset, a very simplified version of the role of the central bank (really, it's all very simplified, it's only a half-hour), and, most importantly, a complete lack of the insanity I'm used to seeing in discussions of economics.

In short, he might not be precisely the exact flavor of Keynesian which is in favor now, but he's obviously not a Marxist, an Austrian Schooler, a goldbug, an anarcho-whatever-you're-not, or any other variety of Flat Earther, so he seems fairly mainstream.

So he's presenting basically sound ideas (as opposed to "Sovereign debt is just like household debt" or "Gold is the only honest money" or "Bankers are pure evil class war villains" or "All government is bad") in a very accessible format. His models are simple, maybe even simplistic, but they're close enough to the mainstream that people who are otherwise out of the loop should be able to follow the discussion intelligently, as opposed to being terrified out of their wits that the government debt is a bigger number than their mortgage.

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by honeybooboo123 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @04:56AM (#8891692)
Spoken like a true sophist.

So anything that's not mainstream is just as crazy as thinking that the earth is flat, huh?

For example, it's decidedly mainstream to believe that ~2% inflation is a good thing, mostly because governments say so.

But it's plain crazy to disagree, realizing that not a single sane person on earth actually wants his purchasing power to decrease, but that's exactly what the 2% inflation does to us.

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by divegeek on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:08AM (#8892512)
Inflation doesn't decrease your purchasing power unless you're living on a fixed, non inflation-adjusted income, or from a limited pool of wealth which you keep in cash.

If you're doing productive work, you can expect your wages to keep pace with inflation, and if they're not, it's very likely that without inflation you'd be seeing wage cuts; your relative value as a worker is independent of inflation. If you're living off of stored wealth, you need to store it in the form of goods, not cash. Real estate, stocks, etc.

There are advantages to inflation. One is that it encourages people to keep their wealth invested in production (aside: This is also part of the economic value proposition for property taxes, which discourage non-productive land-hoarding). Another is that it discounts debt. Because debt payments are not inflation-adjusted and wages effectively are, making your payments gets easier over time. This isn't a good in and of itself, but it's a good when considered against the alternative possibility of deflation, which tends to create insolvency among borrowers. Of course, inflation can harm creditors who don't factor it into their interest rate, but this is less harmful to the economy as a whole.

The ideal would be a money supply that exactly kept pace with growth in production resulting in neither inflation nor deflation. But that's hard. Because mild inflation is not particularly harmful, and deflation is really bad, policymakers prefer to aim for mild inflation as a hedge against deflation.

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by honeybooboo123 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @11:33AM (#8893429)
Yes, salaries are a variable, but even if salaries do rise in sync with inflation, that doesn't make inflation good. It's still bad.

Nope, we can't expect our salaries to rise along with inflation - not in today's insane world.

  - http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/10/09/for-most-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/
  - http://www.theguardian.com/money/2011/nov/23/uk-household-earnings-fall
.. and whatever you'd feel like Googling up.

>> There are advantages to inflation. One is that it encourages people to keep their wealth invested in production

That's not an advantage. Inflation does punish saving (which is bad to begin with), but also encourages risky investments. The higher the inflation, the higher the return on investments you need to not lose wealth, and the riskier your investments, the more likely you're to lose them.

So no, that's not good. Purchasing power increases are good.

>> Another is that it discounts debt.

Yes, this is why governments keep lying to us that inflation is good for us. They're trying to manage their massive debts, but they'll ultimately fail.

How about just not using money you don't have, or money you can't afford to borrow? Oh but that would curtail politicians' crony-capitalist spending, so we can't have that.

>> The ideal would be a money supply that exactly kept pace with growth in production resulting in neither inflation nor deflation

You're basically suggesting that our purchasing power should not increase. That's just absurd.

>> Because mild inflation is not particularly harmful

So even you acknowledge that it is harmful, even if not to a large extent. But what do you get if there's 2% inflation for 10 years? It keeps compounding you know. How much of your purchasing power will you have lost by then?

>> deflation is really bad

No it's not. It's your purchasing power increasing. Everyone wants to get more for less, and that's what (price-)deflation means.

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by divegeek on Thursday January 15, 2015 @06:55PM (#8896290)
Sorry, you're badly confused about a lot of things, but it's not worth the effort to me to educate you. I'll just let you have the last word.
Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by laichzeit0 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @06:39AM (#8891979)
> not a single sane person on earth actually wants his purchasing power to decrease

As with all things in life, this is a tradeoff. I'm willing to concede decreasing purchasing power in exchange for some other advantage. Like I'm willing to exchange shitty battery life for a better and faster web browsing experience on my phone, or how I'm willing to exchange years off my life for some added pleasures like cigarettes and alcohol.

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by honeybooboo123 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @07:05AM (#8892075)
>> I'm willing to concede decreasing purchasing power in exchange for some other advantage

That may be, but that's something everyone should get to choose for themselves. In today's world, we don't, and that's wrong.

Besides, we're not even getting any advantages "in exchange" for losing our purchasing power to the machinations of governments and central banks everywhere. We're just getting milked and fleeced six ways from Sunday all the time.

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by mikeash on Thursday January 15, 2015 @08:40AM (#8892403)
Are you proposing that each person should be able to choose the level of inflation that their own assets are subject to? How would that work?
Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by honeybooboo123 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @11:20AM (#8893347)
Nope, I'm suggesting that we should be able to choose which currency to use. But now we can't.

If we could, we'd choose a sound currency, and then our purchasing power would keep increasing steadily (because of productivity improvements and wealth accumulating over time).

Re:How the Economic Machine Works (2014) by mikeash on Thursday January 15, 2015 @11:48AM (#8893543)
We can't? I mean, I have to obtain USD to pay my taxes, but otherwise I can use currencies at will. I have a hard time finding anyone local who will accept or pay me in anything besides USD, but that's their own choice to do so.