News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by shmerl on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:42PM (#8889957)
> Even if private companies end up contracted to provide it in some cases, those would be regulated monopolies, not regulated free market businesses.

I guess you meant those would be regulated monopolies and not unregulated monopolies ;) ISP scene is quite far from free market at the moment.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by redi90000 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:22PM (#8890354)
I don't understand why people are using monopoly to describe ISPs. Looking at http://www.broadbandmap.gov, can anyone find one city without multiple broadband providers?
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by pgrote on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:44PM (#8890438)
For wired connections my zip code shows 4 providers. This was exciting since there is only 1 right now that is equipped for high speed internet.

The other 3 are dedicated business telecom companies and do not offer residential service.

It appears broadbandmap.gov doesn't differentiate between residential and business.

Looking at the wireless I was excited to see Wimax offered in my zip code according to the site. When I go the provider's map of coverage I only see a small section of the metro area covered and it doesn't include my zip code.

It appears broadbandmap.gov doesn't include the actual wireless coverage provided.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by cpitman on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @10:33PM (#8890753)
This is one of the real issues with the FCC's collection of this data. Broadband providers don't report where they have customers they are providing service, they report areas that they "cover", where "cover" may just mean an intention to provide service. It may also mean that broadband (>3Mbps) is available, for the low low price of your first born.

There's also a potentially anti-competitive slant to this: There are government subsidies available to provide coverage to unserved areas, which might help a small ISP or competitor move into the area. But if we say we cover it...

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by broadband432 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @08:58AM (#8892467)
If you give me your zip code or a surrounding zip code, I can assure you that I'll find more than 1 residential broadband provider in your area.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by mhurron on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:15AM (#8892535)
And of course, if one person in a zip code can get it, everyone can.

I could give you my old Zip code, it would include a small city that had DSL providers and Cable. Where I lived there was one provider, 3mb DSL. That finally showed up about 4 years ago.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by gfdgh54yhgf on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:31AM (#8892604)
Even with 3Mbps, that's still sufficient for vast majority of Americans. Netflix, like the guy said, recommends only 3Mbs. Heck it requires only 0.5MBps[1]

[1] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/306

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by mhurron on Thursday January 15, 2015 @12:51PM (#8894069)
That wasn't the point. The user is saying everywhere has multiple providers to choose from, and it is just not true.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by seanp2k2 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @01:55PM (#8894546)
Ooh, that's funny. I guess you've never lived in apartments where your choice is between up-to-100mbit Comcast or 768K DSL from ATT. I guess LTE is also a choice for high speed if you want to use less than 5GB per month.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by jeffbush on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @11:23PM (#8890874)
In my ZIP, four of the entries are cell phone providers (don't count), AT&T DSL which is listed as 10Mbps+ (I had it; it was only 900kbps), one that is business only (dedicated lines), and a "fixed wireless" provider that is pretty slow and expensive ...and Comcast, which is what I have because it's the only >5Mbps solution available to customers in my neighborhood. I live 15 minutes away from Google's main campus, so it's not like I'm in the sticks or something.

I'm looking at the telephone pole near my house and there are only two wires coming off it: one from Comcast and one from the phone company. And the phone lines can't do more than 1mbps.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by broadband432 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @08:55AM (#8892454)
Why don't they count? AT&T and Verizon are also broadband providers. They're not dial up services. Isn't that the definition of broadband? The cell providers are listed under "Advertised Speeds Above 3 Mbps Data" or above. Just because Comcast has the fastest service doesn't mean it has a monopoly on broadband services. The vast majority of the American population don't need 100Mbps+ anyway. If they did, there would be more competition in that market.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:05AM (#8892505)
The expense and severe limitations of cellular data service rule it out as an equivalent or practical home ISP. It is superior to satellite based service, but that's not saying much.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by seanp2k2 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @01:57PM (#8894561)
>"Why don't they count?" 900kbps from ADSL is not a choice against 30-100+ from DOCSIS
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by FireBeyond on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @10:24PM (#8890733)
Ehhh...

For my home, 2.5mi from the Capital Building in Washington State, I'm offered four wired broadband providers:

1. Comcast, "advertised 100mbps to 1gbps" (true enough, although you can only get 150mbps, so I'm not sure if that's bracketing)

2. CenturyLink, "25-50mbps" (CenturyLink's own website says "Our systems indicate that our High Speed Internet is not currently available at your service address." I tried several other streets in the area that indicated that none of them had availability either.)

3. Platinum Equity LLC, "10-25mbps" (err, Platinum Equity is an investment firm - oh, one of their portfolio offers "T1 and Bonded T1" lines to businesses)

4. Integra Telecom Holdings, "3-6mbps" (a Vancouver telco that does business fiber).

So there's one - Olympia, WA.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by broadband432 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @08:45AM (#8892419)
For Olympia, WA,

http://www.broadbandmap.gov/internet-service-providers/olymp...

There's Comcast, Verizon, ATT, T-Mobile and a host of others.

EDIT: Facts deserve downvotes?

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:18AM (#8892550)
Select "wired" and you're back to what FireBeyond said. One provider. As I replied to you earlier in another thread, cellular internet isn't equivalent, nor is it priced comparably.

http://www.broadbandmap.gov/internet-service-providers/olymp...

re: EDIT: I didn't DV you but you shouldn't be surprised. There probably isn't a single HN'er without direct experience shopping for an ISP, and thus few without the knowledge that the many promises of "broadband" service are often mere pie in the sky.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by gfdgh54yhgf on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:37AM (#8892635)
But the argument here is "broadband monopoly" not "wired broadband monopoly", which municipalities have direct control over on who gets to lay cables. The "broadband monopoly" argument should stop since American consumers aren't limited to one broadband provider.

Anyway, one of the wired ones that's listed (CenturyLink) does residential internet from what I can tell[1]. Another wired one that's also listed for residential in Olympia is MegaPath (owned by Platinum Equity, another wired one)[2].

[1] http://www.centurylink.com/home/internet/

[2] http://www.megapath.com/services-residential/

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday January 15, 2015 @11:16AM (#8893318)
>But the argument here is "broadband monopoly" not "wired broadband monopoly"

No, to repeat myself, cellular wireless ISP service is neither functionally equivalent to other wired nor even to other wireless ISP service offerings. Cellular offers include low data throughput limits, and are not priced comparably. If there were two DSL offerings and one was priced higher for a lower level of service that would also not be reasonably considered a competitive market situation.

As for CenturyLink in Olympia, Wa. the poster already replied that Century Link do not offer service to his/her residence.

I'm not going to audit the claim about Megapath, but instead just assume that FireBeyond was truthful and correct when they said that Megapath did not offer residential services to their address.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by FireBeyond on Thursday January 15, 2015 @12:22PM (#8893810)
Are you going to claim that AT&T offering (typically) a 10GB cap / month (without huge overages) is a realistic broadband offering?

Also - yes, I'm aware CenturyLink does home internet. Not at any of four addresses, including mine and major streets in 98501 where it says they are available according to the original site.

Megapath (the one I found) does residential - in theory. After inputting my service address (and I'm in the heart of the residential area, in a division less than ten years old), here are my options:

1. "Symmetric Ethernet: 6.0M to 45.0M (* Requires Business Account)"

2. "SDSL: 192k" (fairly sure that doesn't meet any current definition of "broadband")

3. "T1: 384k to 3.0M (* Requires Business Account)"

I wouldn't call that a realistic residential broadband offering.

Apropos of anything else, it's as much as you can't just blindly point at broadband.gov and say "look, healthy marketplace!".

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by seanp2k2 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @02:00PM (#8894579)
I don't think anyone on HN is fooled into thinking there is much real competition between ISPs in the US because we've lived it and we know better.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:00AM (#8892477)
Technically, I have four, maybe five choices, only one of which is practical.

Wireless - Poor reception, technicians unable to connect to uplink/head-end equipment

Cellular - Too expensive, data caps, and poor reception (really).

DSL - I used this for four years at my home and was generally satisfied with my private DSL reseller's service. I only left because their service only allowed 1.5Mb, which was no longer satisfactory. Ironically, AT&T now offers 6Mb/s service in my area but DSL resellers apparently aren't permitted to resell "U-verse" even though it is provided via an industry standard protocol, ITU G.992.3

Cable - I have cable now 15Mb, the highest speed they offer. They keep promising to roll out higher speeds, but have yet to do so.

Satellite - Does that count as broadband? Not for me. High latency and low uplink speed rules it out, and expense.

This is an especially crazy situation for me considering that I live near a major internet backbone corridor (0.5mi from my home).

So, strictly speaking there is no monopoly, but the result is hard to distinguish from that of a monopoly/cartel situation.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by jdmichal on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:55PM (#8890466)
That site has... Interesting data. It seems to be granulated based on zip code. It shows, for mine:

1 cable provider

2 ADSL providers

It shows FiOS also, but I can almost guarantee that there is no residence within this zip code that can get it. So, the real question is, how much do you consider ADSL "broadband"?

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by tormeh on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:51AM (#8892701)
Considering most urban ADSL runs at 15/1Mbps standard it very much is broadband. I guess American providers just like having larger distances and thus lower speed on their wires, but there's nothing wrong with ADSL.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by shmerl on Thursday January 15, 2015 @06:09PM (#8896059)
No. A lot of it can't go above 3 Mbps download. 15 is available only if you are very close to the box. So it's definitely not most.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by broadband432 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @08:47AM (#8892425)
What is your zip code? I am quite certain there's just not one residential broadband provider in your area.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by TheCondor on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:43AM (#8892665)
There are loop holes to getting in the database. The wireless providers aren't selling w data rate at every location, they sell a package that can reach that rate in the right locations.

Likewise, why are speeds so low still if there is all that competition? Once the wiring is done, it should be fairly inexpensive to upgrade performance and that should be a pretty clear competitive edge. Are they colluding? Or is it really somehow a noncompetitive market?

I've been in Comcast country a couple times, as soon as there were even whispers of not renewing their franchise, comcast just magically upgraded everyone's performance, I saw that twice. No fee increase.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by shmerl on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @09:29PM (#8890572)
Something like DSL or satellite service is not comparable with others (it's too inferior). As well as a capped service is not comparable. Discarding all that you get something that is clearly a monopoly. Plus several companies which do offer something substantial but operate in collusion are essentially a monopoly anyway.

Real competition is for example Google Fiber or some other small ISP on the scene. That's when you starting getting 1 Gbps for less than $100. But such cases are quite rare still.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by broadband432 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @09:20AM (#8892559)
Going by your definition, does Apple have a monopoly on phones since every other phone is inferior? Just because one broadband provider has greater speeds than the others, it doesn't mean it has a 'broadband monopoly'. Again most Americans don't need 100Mbps+. They are fine with 25Mbps. Netflix only requires 3Mbps.

Now the "cable monopoly" is a separate issue entirely. Comcast has superior speed in some areas because the municipalities create bottlenecks that keep new wires from being laid (like charging exorbitant fees to do so). See, http://www.wired.com/2013/07/we-need-to-stop-focusing-on-jus...

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by shmerl on Thursday January 15, 2015 @11:29AM (#8893399)
Apple has a lot of monopolistic (anti competitive) problems, not just in attitude but in practice. A perfect example is their ban on alternative browsers on iOS. So bringing Apple doesn't help your cause.

> Again most Americans don't need 100Mbps+.

That's a pile of trash and song that monopolists like to sing to justify their unwillingness to upgrade their networks (since if there is nowhere else to turn, their inferior networks will be used for crazy prices anyway - users simply will have no choice). They start singing a very different song when they face actual competition. They quickly forget their previous claims that no one needs more bandwidth and start offering it. Which just demonstrates how sick the current ISP market is.

I.e. imagine you are trying to find a transport service, and local transportation company tells you that their horse and buggy service is just fine, because no one needs anything better (didn't everyone use it for hundreds of years already?). And then their competitor actually builds a railroad... You get the idea - that's exactly what's going on with ISPs now.