News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by WillNotDownvote on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:30PM (#8889238)
A thought that occurs to me is that if the government is providing internet access, various pressure groups will leverage that for various kinds of censorship.

Why is my government providing access to porn? To religious sites? To sites that violate copyright? To sites that contain many sorts of 'unsavory' content? Allowing children uncensored access to many things?

I don't know how those complaints would fare, but I'm absolutely certain they'd be made.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by jfb on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:03PM (#8889440)
It seems to me that the right level for government to be involved in these sorts of questions is the municipality itself, rather than running back to Federal statute. Which is, again, orthogonal to preventing Verizon-owned statehouses from passing laws preventing municipal broadband networks.

This is a very light touch intervention to increase market-based competition. How much more quickly would there be privately owned fiber networks if consumers had the option of going to City Internet for $150/GB/s?

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by freehunter on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:53PM (#8889696)
The Internet generally has fallen under inter-state regulations, which is governed by the federal government.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by derekp7 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:46PM (#8889987)
They already do this, with these things called roads. In fact, I saw a tax-payer funded road that gave access to a church, a bar, and an adult store.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by danans on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:16PM (#8890106)
A tax-funded road built with the explicit the purpose of giving access to all three of these? Did the places exist there before the road, and if so, how did people get to them? Are the places located very close to each other or just coincidentally on the same road that stretches a long distance?
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by derekp7 on Thursday January 15, 2015 @10:22AM (#8892897)
So I take it that you are agreeing that there is no fundamental difference between a road and the internet, when it comes to people complaining about the government using tax dollars to facilitate access to undesirable places?
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by danans on Saturday January 17, 2015 @02:10AM (#8903741)
Not sure what the downvotes were for. What I asked were honest questions about the road that was described. I think that are many similarities and differences between a road and the internet with regard to whether they should be tax funded.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by aqme28 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:26PM (#8889571)
It's definitely an issue that will be raised, so I don't know why you're downvoted. Ideally, people would realize that it's roughly the equivalent of using public electricity for unsavory things.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday January 15, 2015 @06:18AM (#8891915)
Except that filtering/censorship/monitoring don't have to work at the municipal level.

The UK's (big) ISPs are already required to 'offer' Internet filtering to all customers, collect activity logs, and prevent access to certain torrent sites.

None of them have had a problem implementing this at a national level.

(Setting up a DNS blacklist/redirect isn't hard - you do it in your network/backbone gateways, which aren't anywhere near your subscribers.)

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by Crito on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:18PM (#8889844)
Why is my government delivering porno mags and religious pamphlets to my mailbox?

The government being in the delivery business is nothing new. Historically, it has worked out for the better more often than not.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by zaroth on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:52PM (#8890019)
So the premise is then any government infra to provide broadband must come with equally stringent protections on monitoring the content, similar to how government infra to provide deliveries has warrant requirements to inspect those deliveries.

However, we know that government policy is to record all meta-data, forever, without a warrant. HTTP/2 can't come fast enough, but even that doesn't really hide enough meta-data to trust the government with the pipe. E.g. You can tell fairly well what static pages on a domain someone is visiting by simply correlating the size of the response packets.

Of course, they are already doing all of this already, so maybe the ship has sailed... I think the best model is that the government provides the fiber, the L2 and above service is provided by a private entity. It certainly doesn't do much to prevent mass-collection or censorship, but it's marginally better than the Fed actually providing Layer 2.

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by Jtsummers on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:44PM (#8889335)
This is already an issue faced by other government entities that provide access to the internet. See libraries. Their solution is to leave it open because it's not their place to censor. Parents already have (I assume faulty, never checked it out myself) software solutions to block "unsavory" content.
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by zerocrates on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:00PM (#8889420)
Libraries already have to use internet filtering/blocking software under CIPA (though adult users are supposed to be able to get the filter disabled).
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by WillNotDownvote on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:01PM (#8889427)
Right, and libraries in various municipalities are in fact censored, both in terms of publications and in internet access they allow.

Why would this be different?

Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by wglb on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:31PM (#8889595)
How are they censored? Do you have any examples of this?
Re:Obama calls for municipal broadband by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday January 15, 2015 @11:30AM (#8893407)
The public library a few hundred feet from my residence heavily and ridiculously censors its internet access. The censorship is provided by a third party and getting a site whitelisted is practically impossible to achieve.