Diversity is what makes life. If you attach future earning potential qualifier to the free education, then you'll have a disproportionate amount of people attempting fit their square potential into a round hole.
Over a long period of time, you loose out the natural diversity that would otherwise exist in the general public - of people each dedicated to skill set they are best match for.
Not everything human produces ought to have an economic component.
Painters, Poets, Musicians... ?
This is great. But then we need to stop talking about "investment" in college education. This is instead "consumption," like taking a ski trip to Aspen.
How much should the US pay for people to take ski trips to Aspen? I promise you they'll enjoy it.
Sending everyone to community college to learn various things produces a benefit to society that might not translate to economic benefit for that particular person.
An educated populace is good for a democracy.
So in the context of an environment where we encourage extended education via monetary assistance, we strip away all forms of assistance for the study of history due to some qualifier. Is this wise?
They might not watch, but they might not attend college, either. Well, we can get them to attend college if use the college degree as a job credential so they can't get a good job without it, but that seems like a cruel policy, especially cruel to the least smart in society, so I don't think you'd want that.
Can you explain why someone needs a college education to become a painter, poet or musician?
Your sentiment can be applied to any skillset. The same reason why a college degree is not needed for programmers.. One can learn concepts and languages from books outside of college. However the resources available in a community of like-minded individuals provides great benefit for the study of said topic.
Colleges are not the only such environment. But it is the most expensive.
>>Your sentiment can be applied to any skillset.
Not really, no. Would you let a doctor without w college degree operate on you? Have your city's bridges and buildings designed and built by engineers and architects who learned their trades from books?
In the end, there are no perfect answers to any of this, it's just a question of "which variables do you optimize for?"
Otherwise, you have to ask "is this education, or indoctrination?"
Good point. Paying for somebody to get a degree in, say, Medieval History, so they only job they can get post-college is "Barista at Starbucks", seems suboptimal to me.