Re:The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Decline...
by wanderingstan on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:44AM
(#8886137)
I've read the book and would not call it exploratory at all--it is lengthy and exhaustive. I found myself skimming over additional supporting data in many cases.
I'm most interested in accusations that he cherry-picked his sources or data, and I haven't seen any of these backed up. (Other than rambling rants like the above "criticism" which says that adjusting for world population is "massaging the numbers".)
Edit: typos
From the comments I am reading here I am gathering that Pinker's work is exploratory and not scientific (keep in mind that I have not read it myself). If that is the case then there are no grounds for a counterpoint.
Exploratory works can be used as a framework on which to build points and counterpoints, but attempting to disprove them is a fundamental error.
All it comes down to is this default argumentative state that the internet seems to have.