News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by phaus on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:39PM (#8884130)
>the libertarian ideals that justify the existence of Silk Road should have their day in court

Real trials don't play out like they do in hollywood. You don't get to spend your time in court talking about your ideology and lobbying for better laws. The entire trial will be about whether or not he's guilty of breaking the laws that already exist.

Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by dmix on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @11:10PM (#8884240)
The defense can object to letting him explain his libertarian viewpoints if they can convince the judge it is not relevant to the case or charges. Which the prosecutor in this case directly attempted during pretrial last month:

> Prosecutors in the case against alleged Silk Road mastermind Ross Ulbricht want the court to prohibit Ulbricht from saying almost anything political at all, according to a motion filed last week by the government.

> They’re worried that the jury might end up sympathizing with Ulbricht’s politics.

http://www.dailydot.com/politics/silk-road-jury-nullificatio...

Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by themartorana on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @11:22AM (#8887199)
I'll never understand this - the ability to petition for the judge to disallow a valid defense, because they're scared it might work. That's the entire point of a defense.

To me, this goes against every freedom of speech. To not be allowed to defend yourself in any and every way possible is to not be free.

Edit: "in any and every truthful way possible" - obviously perjury is perjury.

Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by phaus on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:36PM (#8887721)
He shouldn't be allowed to express political views during the trial. It isn't a valid defense because his political views are completely unrelated to the matters at hand. The only purpose of the trial is to determine whether or not he did the things the government says he did. If he did them, then he broke existing laws.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by themartorana on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:09PM (#8887933)
If that were true, there would be no such thing as Jury Nullification. As long as the concept both exists and is valid, a defense that argues the law itself is in fact a completely valid defense.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by mindslight on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @11:20PM (#8884279)
If he were being tried by a jury of his peers, it would not need explaining.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:18AM (#8884466)
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by phaus on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:40PM (#8887740)
And this is why I hope I never end up on trial for anything. Some types of people are more easy to dislike than others. For example, I have asperger's. I'm pretty certain that if I ever went on trial for anything, my personality would increase the chances that I get convicted.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by dmix on Thursday January 15, 2015 @01:26PM (#8894333)
Criminal lawyers don't let defendants talk for a reason, that is their job.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by cynicalkane on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @11:37PM (#8884330)
That's not what a "jury of one's peers" is.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by neotek on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:46AM (#8885031)
You're missing my point: I don't want him to stand up in court and lecture on the nature of freedom and personal responsibility like something out of Inherit The Wind, I would just like to see him take the rap for what he (probably) did without this silly "it was the one armed man" defense.

It's not about the trial, because the trial is lost no matter what he does (regardless of whether or not he's innocent, he's going to jail, guaranteed), it's about nailing your colours to the wall and showing the rest of the world that you're willing to go to jail to stand up for the freedoms you ostensibly believe in.

Ulbricht won't be doing any of that, instead he's going to mount a defense that effectively says that his manifesto, his politics, his core beliefs, are all just something to be discarded when it's convenient.

Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by phaus on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:33PM (#8887704)
Ahh OK. It appears I did misunderstand you. Well, if he actually did do the things that the government is claiming, I still wouldn't look at him like he's a champion for libertarian ideals. The person who took the actions of which he is accused is interested in only one thing: money.
Re:Silk Road Defense Says Ulbricht Was Framed by the ‘Real’ ... by therealwill on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:40AM (#8886109)
So you want him to be a martyr? With the murder for hire accusations I doubt it...