News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by munificent on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:13PM (#8882256)
> The indie dev scene is thriving on PC.

Back when I was a console developer at EA, the ambient wisdom was that the money was falling out of (non-online) PC games in large part because of piracy.

Is that not the case? Do you happen to have numbers on what the PC game industry is like? How much of this is because of Steam?

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by ANTSANTS on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:36PM (#8882774)
When did you work there?

What you heard at EA applies to AAA console devs. If you're gambling everything on a blockbuster game with an enormous budget, it's true, I don't think it would be smart to make a PC exclusive today. That has everything to do with the crazy budget management, retail relationships, unsatisfiable consumer expectations, and unsustainable nature of the western AAAs, though. When a game like Bioshock Infinite can sell over six million copies and the developer still goes out of business, there is something deeply wrong with your business model.

If you are an indie, it's totally different. You can do everything on a very small budget with a very small team, perhaps even by yourself. You can plan to break even in the thousands or tens of thousands of copies sold, not millions. You can target the long tail instead of making or breaking your company on the first week of sales. You can have a direct relationship with your fans. Piracy changes from a death sentence to free marketing.

So for indies, PC is a clear win, because:

It's where most of the people that like indie games are.

The dev tools are free and available this second. You don't need to pay or sign an NDA and go through an approval process for dev kits, you don't need to pay for QA, you don't need to go through another QA process to push updates, you don't need a publisher. Just go and make your game.

There is no single gatekeeper. You always have the option to pick another digital distribution store or sell the game yourself. Even if you plan to rely completely on Steam, this fact makes Valve much more lenient and easier to deal with than Sony or Microsoft.

Most importantly, you can give people your game in a zip file. Free betas are awesome, especially for unproven developers. You get free word of mouth marketing, free playtesting, often great advice in early stages of development before it's "too late" to change things, and the peace of mind that people actually like your game and will buy it when you're finished. Do not underestimate the power of the free beta, it is easily the greatest benefit of the PC platform, and has singlehandedly made countless indie devs, even back before they called them that.

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by mattmanser on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @06:55PM (#8883409)
Bioshock Infinite's developer did not go out of business at all.

It was deliberately shut down.

http://www.mcvuk.com/news/read/myths-busted-who-killed-irrat...

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by wlesieutre on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:28PM (#8882374)
EA is chasing a very different segment of the market than indie developers. Fancy graphics and gigantic projects that need to sell millions to break even. At that scale (and aiming at the lowest common denominator of consumers) maybe piracy is a big deal, but there are indie games that seem to do ok.

Their problem isn't piracy so much as getting noticed with a marketing budget orders of magnitude smaller than most AAA games'. And to be honest, I suspect EA just likes using piracy as a boogeyman to blame their problems on and to rationalize the Origin service.

I don't know that overall numbers on the PC industry would shed much light on the indie dev scene since they're still a small fraction, but I've played a lot of great games in the last few years. On mobile I basically stopped bothering, with Monument Valley being the one recent exception.

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by delucain on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:27PM (#8882726)
I think you've hit it right on this. I'd also add that the cost variations probably do play a big factor into what piracy does exist. I'm a lot more likely to take a shot in the dark on a $7 indie game or even a $30 indie "blockbuster" than I am a $60 AAA game (where half the cost is marketing anyway). Piracy probably just appeals more at the higher price points.
Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by benihana on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @06:05PM (#8883215)
I'm not sure how much of the success it attributable to Steam, and how much of it is just a consequence of the times - lots of cheap tech, lots of people using cheap tech, and most importantly, video games being something everyone does. In the 80s and 90s, video games were for geeks. Ha, in my freshman year of college in 2001, my roommates were baffled that I would put on a headset and seemingly talk to my computer while playing a game on it?

Anyway, I will say the Steam Early Access program is amazing. It basically lets developers develop games in a Lean-Startup style, by releasing an MVP and then iterating on it, and it lets customers buy the game at any point to fund the development.

I've been playing Kerbal Space Program (highly recommended if you're interested at all in spaceflight, orbital mechanics or rocketry) on the Early Release Program, and it's just awesome. The developers are cool and are pretty at-large in the community on reddit.

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by deciplex on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @09:11PM (#8883875)
Early Access is a crapshoot though, and I'm glad Valve is taking steps to rein it in a bit. Too many developers start with basically a POC, sell it at normal release price points, and then development peters out after that. Godus and DF-9 are good examples of this.

Strangely, it seems that you should avoid Early Access when it's for games by [i]established[/i] developers (Peter Molyneux and Tim Schafer are behind Godus and DF-9, respectively). Meanwhile KSP was made by a bunch of (former) nobodies, who actually made a game that delivers everything they've ever promised.

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by lacker on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @11:47PM (#8884361)
Too many developers start with basically a POC, sell it at normal release price points, and then development peters out after that.

It seemed like this happened with Minecraft, it was just popular enough that the POC was good enough.

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by happimess on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:48AM (#8885258)
Surely you're joking--Notch gave away the POC for free, and started charging for the beta somewhere before 2011 (when I started playing). Since then, new features and bug fixes have been essentially non-stop.

I picked it up after a long hiatus and found new terrain types, new monsters, new neutral creatures, an enchanting system, a brewing system, an entirely new dimension ("The End"), and several types of abandoned structures.

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by kllrnohj on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:43PM (#8887758)
Minecraft's price has increased slowly as the game got more and more stuff, and the pace of improvements and additions has increased significantly over time.

Minecraft today is $27 (and totally worth every penny and then some), but this is very much not what Minecraft cost 2 years ago. The alpha version was €9.95 and the beta was €14.95.

So no this is not at all what happened with Minecraft.

Re:The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer by deciplex on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:58PM (#8890484)
Yeah, this is the way to do it, and I hope it starts to get more common on Steam and other platforms.

Charging full price for alpha versions of your game, then putting it on sale once it's done, is a slap in the face to your biggest fans - and the people who will most likely help you succeed via word of mouth.