Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by Karunamon on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:10PM
(#8882235)
That leaves a question of collisions open. The chances are really low, but not zero - does a hash match automatically generate events that lead to your front door being kicked open and your pets shot, or is there an actual human that needs to open the file and verify that yeah, it is a child abuse image?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by sz4kerto on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:13PM
(#8882258)
Hey, they _have_ that picture. If there is a hash collision, then a human will look at it. (Not that hash collisions are _that_ common.)
Why would they come to your door for the stuff you store at them? :)
Edit: you mentioned lottery below. Well, waiting for a collision in the case of a good hash function is a lottery where nobody's winning for a few billion years :).
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by Paul-ish on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:13PM
(#8882261)
With any good hash function there is pretty much zero risk of this happening.
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by Karunamon on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:15PM
(#8882277)
I'm not willing to ruin someone's life over the equivalent of winning a particularly bad lottery.
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by Retra on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @05:01PM
(#8882917)
A hash collision is not proof of anything. You just look at the picture if the hash matches. It is not illegal to own an image that hashes to the same thing as an illegal image would.
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by Scaevolus on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:39PM
(#8882441)
Your chances of having your life ruined by any other cause is at least 2^64 times more likely than because your uploaded cute_cat.jpg has the same hash as a flagged child_porn.jpg.
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by dagw on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @05:10PM
(#8882972)
I'm assuming we're not talking about SHA1 hashes here (which would be trivial to get around), but image matching hashes (probably something like http://phash.org/) which are much more fuzzy. If that is the case then collisions will be far more common.
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by eli on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:40PM
(#8882448)
Depending on the exact hash, the odds might be more like winning 10,000 lotteries.
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn
by Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:55PM
(#8882900)
Note that we're talking about fuzzy image-matching hashs that attempt to match an image to its source even after it was cropped at the edges, maybe got a new watermark somewhere and was recompressed with JPEG a few times. I don't know the false positive rate of these algorithms but I imagine they're much bigger than that of a cryptographic hash function (that's what analogies like yours usually refer to).