News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn by dmix on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @02:38PM (#8882001)
Google also scans gmail attachments for it as well. This has been known for a while and the subject of quite a few public court cases. I wouldn't be surprised if Dropbox did it as well. Along with things of national security interest.

When local police get a warrant to do a forensic search of computers the judge often requires that they search harddrives using known image/file hashes - as opposed to looking through each file by hand - in order to protect that persons constitutional right to privacy.

This right primarily applies to personal computers and doesn't exist (as clearly) as defined by law when the files are stored on a remote cloud service. Although whether cloud services have a similar high threshold of assumed privacy is a recurring debate in criminal law, as storing your whole life in cloud services is a relatively new phenomenon.

Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn by higherpurpose on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @02:42PM (#8882029)
Is Google doing it as well supposed to make me feel better or worse? That kind of logic always bothers me, because it bypasses the arguments about whether it's good or wrong, and just says "well others are doing it, too - so it must be okay". It's like saying "well UK tortured as well, so why does it matter that US tortured?" I think you get my point.

I also doubt that if they get a warrant, they'll only scan the drives for the hashes. That seems highly unlikely unless the FBI/prosecutors themselves specify in their request to the judge that they only want to do the hash scanning - but I don't see why they would want to limit themselves to that, when they know the judge is likely to give them full access to it, if they already have some evidence of "criminal activity", without which I assume they wouldn't even bother getting a warrant.

Re:OneDrive data automatically scanned for child porn by dmix on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @02:45PM (#8882045)
> That seems highly unlikely unless the FBI/prosecutors themselves specify in their request to the judge that they only want to do the hash scanning

It depends on the case I guess. I heard this from a lawyer I know who has worked on CP cases. Judges always try to limit the privacy exposure in every warrant. By doing so the police can get access to warrants easier since it requires a lower threshold of probable cause than say searching an entire house.

Especially if the police found the person because they used a P2P site to download a particular file or had a hash in their email account. A minimal warrant to search for that hash is much easier to defend in court against arguments by the defense of constitutional privacy violations of a full data search.

The police have to do this minimization process in phone wiretaps as well. They aren't supposed to listen nor store the phone call unless the information is relevant to the case.

These limitations are clearly defined in warrants. It is up to the police and forensic experts to follow it of course. But I'd imagine in high profile cases the Judge/FBI wouldn't think twice about finding it appropriate to look at every file.