Re:Reimplementing TeX's Algorithms: Looking Back at Thirty Y...
by taeric on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:55AM
(#8880574)
Oh, I am not against the excercise. I would even go so far as to applaud the work. What I do not care for, is essentially sloppy science in how we declare successes.
I mean, this is essentially back-seat driving Knuth, of all people.
And... TeX has been widely ported as is. I am in the crowd that is somewhat unconvinced it needs a rewrite.
That said, I personally don't see a lot of value in being too critical of projects with different goals. (That feels a little bit like back-seat driving where you have a different destination in mind than the person behind the wheel.) If someone has the motivation and creativity to embark on a project, good for them.
If you or someone else wants to port TeX with different goals, that's also fine.
In any case, until Glenn's source code is available, neither one of us can say very much about the code he has written.