I do not agree. A competitor with an optimized page will pay less and rank higher even in the payed result. It is not as simple as the one who payes the most will rank highest, Google has a quality score for Adwords landing pages that will effect your ranking in the payed result as well as what you pay per click.
You main point is valid. You can buy traffic from lots of places and that traffic is often very good. But organic traffic can still make up a big part of your revenue and shouldn't be ignored.
Our organic efforts are much more fruitful.
Incorrect. Specific percentages vary from study to study, but on average no more than 30% of clicks on a search results page are on ads, leaving 70%+ for organic results.
Remember that SEO is optimization. It can't replace ads, but the more traffic you can get organically, the more profit you can make, and then you'll have more to spend on ads. It's a virtuous cycle.
And success is relative. If you're not doing any SEO, and your competitor does it half-assed, well, then their average visitor cost is going to be less than yours--and that's a competitive advantage.
Most people will just click on the first few "results", even if they are in fact ads. They can hardly tell the difference. That's why businesses are paying so much to be on top of certain lucrative search key terms: if they we not getting a return on their advertising spend, then they would not be spending it.
My main point is, even if your website is horribly un-optimized in terms of SEO, if you have a bucket of cash to spend on Adwords, you will still get a tonne of traffic. SEO in this instance is almost irrelevant.