News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Known Software Bug’ Disrupts Brain-Tumor Zapping by jacquesm on Saturday October 17, 2009 @05:02PM (#887427)
Wow.

Why would a bug like that not lead to an instant communication to halt all use of the devices until a patch could be distributed ?

Good thing the couch wasn't driven by a worm-wheel or there would have been no way to pull that person out.

An emergency switch should be independent of software anyway, that's the norm in machining tools, the 'e-stop' circuitry has to be set up according to very specific rules to be approved, you'd expect more stringent controls on hospital equipment.

Re:‘Known Software Bug’ Disrupts Brain-Tumor Zapping by jrockway on Saturday October 17, 2009 @05:15PM (#887440)
An emergency switch should be independent of software anyway

Good advice. Essential for things that cut you or shoot radiation at you.

It would also be nice if consumer electronics devices did this. I remember badly reflashing my iPod once; the reflash locked up and the iPod was stuck displaying a message without the backlight on. There was no way to reboot it without waiting for the battery to drain itself (or to open the device up). This took a few days, but I did get it working again.

A simple hardware reset switch would have saved me a lot of time. I don't buy Apple products anymore.

Re:‘Known Software Bug’ Disrupts Brain-Tumor Zapping by joechung on Saturday October 17, 2009 @05:27PM (#887453)
Re:‘Known Software Bug’ Disrupts Brain-Tumor Zapping by jrockway on Sunday October 18, 2009 @01:06AM (#888001)
This apparently does not work when a firmware flash has gone south. I tried the various combinations a million times while waiting for the battery to go flat :)
Re:‘Known Software Bug’ Disrupts Brain-Tumor Zapping by RK on Saturday October 17, 2009 @05:24PM (#887448)
This type of equipment has many failsafes and lockouts, but clearly the electronic emergency release and radiation door closing didn't work in this case. The scandal is that is was a known bug. Obviously this bug only occurred in a specific scenario, because the clinics are required to test the emergency procedures on a regular basis.

In this case the US regulatory agency, NRC, initiated an investigation and forced Elekta to fix it. It sounds like they assumed it wasn't critical enough from the initial report that all treatments with this model should stop before the patch was distributed (the incident happened months ago).

Re:‘Known Software Bug’ Disrupts Brain-Tumor Zapping by bmj on Saturday October 17, 2009 @07:43PM (#887629)
As someone who works with software that is audited by the FDA (we build devices to collect data for clinical drug trials), I'm assuming the regulatory agency knew about this issue before the equipment was certified for use. Any bugs that we defer from a product release are documented, and therefore reviewed by anyone that decides to audit the company. We are routinely asked by auditors to explain why certain bugs were deferred prior to release.
Re:‘Known Software Bug’ Disrupts Brain-Tumor Zapping by tomjen2 on Saturday October 17, 2009 @07:45PM (#887631)
The problem with that is that not using the machine can also cost lives.