News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by aleyan on Sunday January 11, 2015 @09:19PM (#8872194)
To get pleasantries out of the way, I am glad to see Matt Turck here on HN. The meetup he hosts, Data Driven NYC, attracts a large number of both very high caliber of guest speakers and attendees. The several times I have been there, I enjoyed the presentations and the discussions afterwards thoroughly. X.ai which I was introduced to at this meetup, was one of the more interesting startups there. If I wasn't as happy as I am at Handy, x.ai would be foremost among companies I would consider working at; their challenges are many. This is one of the highest endorsements can be bestowed upon a firm and its product by an engineer.

While x.ai is very exciting, I have several concerns about their product and their chances at success.

1) Most meetings are scheduled internally within a firm where calendars are visible and shared. An AI PA that simply locks down time slots doesn't have much value add beyond what the calendars currently provide.

2) There are privacy concerns. Many will not trust x.ai with their calendar data due to concerns about x.ai data-mining or sharing their data.

3) There are other privacy concerns. People may not trust Amy and Andrew not to be social engineered by others to leak their calendars. The fact that person is busy at a certain time or for a certain duration or within a certain vicinity is potentially useful to people whose goals are more than just scheduling a meeting. This kind of over sharing may not be worse than goes on with Facebook, but the letters A.I. will make it sound scarier.

My last point is a wish. Most of my non-work meetings are scheduled over #1 text messaging and #2 Facebook. I would like to see x.ai support other mediums than just email.

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by lbotos on Sunday January 11, 2015 @09:35PM (#8872238)
Why does the A.I. part of the situation make social engineering scarier?
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by aleyan on Sunday January 11, 2015 @10:02PM (#8872312)
1) Perceived Risk. AI makes any activity 10 times scarier than same activity without. People will irrationally fear that their AI PA turns into HAL 9000[1] or their self-driving car turns into Project Satan[2].

2) Actual Risk. Software has bugs. When software is meant to give out some subset of data it is not unknown for it to give out more data than it means to. A human PA may make mistakes and blurb something that he/she shouldn't have, but he/she also knows when to stop giving out information. If a particularly trained AI starts leaking out information, it will happily do so for user after user after user.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HAL_9000 [2] http://futurama.wikia.com/wiki/Project_Satan

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by graycat on Sunday January 11, 2015 @10:04PM (#8872317)
Where's the AI part?

The video clip talked about learning -- what's to learn?

For the sharing of calendars, why is that necessary?

So, my software sends you and three other people e-mail asking for a meeting with all of us somewhere in NYC Midtown next week.

So, each of you sends back some candidate times.

If you have the same software, it grabs the e-mail (say, from some tag in the header lines) and sends back to my e-mail some candidate times. My software answers, and there is a negotiation. If each person invited has the same software, then the software can negotiate, very soon, when all the software agents can be available to negotiate with my software agent, and then the negotiation can go really fast.

Sure, if your software proposes several times and my software won't accept any of those, then someone looking at the e-mail flows could find times when I was busy. A biggie? Maybe not.

Once all the agents are available, they could negotiate how to communicate peer to peer, that is, faster than e-mail, and really extensive negotiations could be done in less than a second. And the peer to peer traffic could be encrypted and, really, not easily available otherwise, that is, relatively secure.

My agent could have my appointments already and know when I will be at a meeting in NJ and consider my travel time to NYC Midtown to know when I could be available at Midtown.

What else to do?

What's wrong with that outline?

Where's the AI or the learning needed?

Yes, there could be some high push for virality and a network effect.

But, then, still, there's no very good barrier to entry. I.e., it's awfully easy to program, and if the scheduling software of some one company wants to schedule only with other copies of their software, then a disrupting company could offer to have open communications and be willing to schedule with other software. Then this little idea would go for nearly a freebie, and no one would make any money.

Ah, but encrypted communications and communicating with other software combine to yield a security problem -- anyone could write fake software that would report the unencrypted data. More generally, does look hackable so that there would be security risks.

Maybe a must-have for some people, but if they are meeting outside their office then there's a lot of travel likely. In that case, maybe use video conferencing.

I don't see much of a business opportunity there.

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by fchollet on Sunday January 11, 2015 @10:53PM (#8872421)
> Where's the AI needed?

Marketing, I assume. Giving people their very own Jarvis to interact with could be a selling point (even if it's less efficient than a GUI-based scheduling solution), and the "AI" buzzword will certainly draw more attention to the product than a scheduling app would normally get.

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by dmortensen on Monday January 12, 2015 @12:05AM (#8872590)
Building a conversation model which can negotiate with multiple guests on behalf of the host in plain english is not easy (for us). This includes simple social concepts such as "compromise" - say, when to push for one location over another. The information extraction problem alone is a major challenge.

No buzzwords needed, we are just trying to do some good work, and if we succeed, we think many people would like it: https://twitter.com/search?q=xdotai

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by fchollet on Monday January 12, 2015 @12:21AM (#8872620)
Good luck with your company, I wish you succeed. NLP is certainly no piece of cake.
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by graycat on Monday January 12, 2015 @12:43AM (#8872671)
> plain English

Gads. That's tough to do well, and as a user I'd always wonder if the software got it right unless I just kept checking.

And why try with plain English? Heck, long ago I commonly wrote Fortran programs with very easy to use input: Start with a file that asks for all the data. Each line of that file starts with some character to indicate that the line is such a request and with, say, a number, to indicate what request it is. Then a user just types in their data after each such request. It's dirt simple to implement and for users to use. So, for human readable input, just do it that way. Natural language understanding -- f'get about it.

Once I programmed something where the human input was a lot like XML -- really simple to use.

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by dmortensen on Monday January 12, 2015 @08:31AM (#8873754)
I agree and I could easily see myself use something like that. However, I want something (naively perhaps) which my Mom can use. My worst nightmare is one where early users inadvertently create some sort of "syntax" which my mom use to discard this as a service for her. Like she discarded the idea of twitter, because people created a RT, MT $bla #bla etc. "syntax".
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by graycat on Monday January 12, 2015 @10:01AM (#8874165)
Your goal is fine, fully appropriate. Of course your mom should be able to use it; anyone who can type and read should be able to use it. Fine. And there is no need for any nonsense gibberish such as "RT, MT".

But, I believe you are over estimating the importance of having some natural language understanding, under estimating the difficulty of achieving that understanding reliably in software, and are very much under estimating how easy to use, even for your mother, for anyone who can type, something like I outlined can be.

E.g., when I was in grad school, I took out some time to earn some money so that my wife and I could complete our Ph.D. degrees. For the money, I worked as an applied mathematician, computer guy in a research shop doing work mostly for the US Navy. So, yes, we had secretaries who did a lot of typing but had no word processing.

As part of my work in applied math, I ended up as system administrator of a super-mini computer. Of course, for programming, it had a text editor. If only for writing the computer manuals, it had a simple text formatting program, call it a member of the family of Runoff programs. And I'd gotten a daisy wheel printer nicely driven -- asynchronous serial communications with ASCII characters and the XON/XOFF handshaking (pacing) protocol -- by the computer. So, we were GO to do a LOT of typing.

Soon enough the secretaries wanted to get on board with this new stuff. So, for them, one at a time, we pulled some 5 conductor, general purpose signal cable with a 25 pin plug at each end (we only connected the pins for the signals SEND, RECEIVE, and SIGNAL GROUND), and a dumb terminal.

Bottom line: All the secretaries got on board right away. The ones without a terminal begged for one. No one ever gave one of the secretaries more than a few minutes of 'training'. They all caught on right away, to logon, files, the hierarchical file system, the text editor, the runoff program, the daisy wheel printer, etc. Right away.

Later as a college prof, I did the same for the business school, and again the secretaries 'got it' right away.

Gee, we weren't asking them to write macros in TeX!

So, back to my suggestion:

You want an appointment. So, you send something like

     === May we meet?  Let's pick a time and place.

     === My name

     === My job

     === My e-mail address

     === My phone number

     === Subject of meeting

     === When to meet

     === Where to meet
or some such. Then you use just typing to insert data under each of these or some such, likely need something better, but you get the idea, and send your e-mail.

A human, including your mother, can read it and respond. And they can respond with a similar e-mail.

If either end of the communications is using your software, then the software can read that data and make sense of it much easier than for natural language processing.

Or, send the person some e-mail with a URL to a server with a Web page with a form and some JavaScript to help the person fill out the form. Then we're into just a Web form solution that we know very well how to handle.

Forms work great; people are really good at entering data into forms.

For people who have your app, it can replace the Web site.

No way do you have to use gibberish such as "RT, MT". Instead, everything a user reads can be in complete English sentences with a button with Help for more explanations, etc. It can be easier to use than most Web forms, and 1+ billion people use those. It can be easier to use than Google, e.g., where Google has those little horizontal bars to indicate (I never got that memo or read any explanation in a help message) for more options. Last I checked, Google had a lot of users. It can be easier to use than the Amazon Web site, easier to use than Facebook.

You are underestimating the ability of your target users to make use of simple computer user interfaces.

My guess is that there is no way natural language processing can be good enough that, net, it is easier to use than just some simple forms or something like I outlined above.

Gibberish like "RT, MT" is really a straw man to knock down. Instead, never but never should there ever be any gibberish or undefined terminology or undefined acronyms in any user interface. That rule is easy to obey, and natural language processing is a very hard way to obey it.

The real business need and opportunity is meeting scheduling, not finding work for natural language processing.

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by xerophyte12932 on Monday January 12, 2015 @02:52AM (#8872871)
Well the scheduling program works as your PA, and is expected to deal with other humans who want to schedule meetings with you. So not only does it have to understand their correspondence, it also has to negotiate with them. This requires NLP
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by graycat on Monday January 12, 2015 @10:20AM (#8874261)
I can't agree. In short, the communications can be done with forms, on a smartphone, Web site, or similar.
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by xerophyte12932 on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @12:00AM (#8878243)
As someone else mentioned, that would require the other party to click a link and be directed to some webpage for said form. I agree, that's not too much of a hassle and in my instances can be far more effective than setting up a meeting on email (for example if it displays the free slots of all involved parties like doodle.com), but that's what x.ai is offering: letting people scedule the way they already do
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by woah on Monday January 12, 2015 @04:11AM (#8873008)
Building expertise in the field. I believe that the goal was first of all to apply ai to a problem that seemed approachable. If they can keep it going, they will have more than enough expertise for a pivot into something more exciting with their machine learning tech.
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by fezz on Monday January 12, 2015 @12:12AM (#8872605)
AI is the new hip cool thing to get VCs excited about the same old same old.

Algorithm != AI

Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by sushirain on Monday January 12, 2015 @03:37PM (#8876265)
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect : AI researcher Rodney Brooks complains "Every time we figure out a piece of it, it stops being magical; we say, 'Oh, that's just a computation.'"
Re:AI-Powered Meeting Scheduler X.ai Raises $9.2M Series A by graycat on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @11:19AM (#8880729)
> "Oh, that's just a computation."

He expected something else?