Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by sillysaurus3 on Sunday January 11, 2015 @07:56PM
(#8871994)
Completely agreed. Once Microsoft releases the VS source code, I'll be completely sold on the idea that it's reformed. Until then, this seems like very effective developer relations management.
Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by nbevans on Sunday January 11, 2015 @11:59PM
(#8872583)
Why the VS source code? It would be almost entirely useless to anybody as there is 2 decades of legacy in that code base and MS has massive teams just trying to keep it all together. Only open source things that are WORTH open sourcing i.e. where you want active contributors.
Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by jenscow on Monday January 12, 2015 @03:58AM
(#8872983)
Why VS? So when things are removed, "we" can continue to maintain them. Sure, that provides no benefit for Microsoft but it does to its customers. It will also show the are serious about being "all open", rather than a few self-satisfying token gestures.
Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 12, 2015 @03:49AM
(#8872965)
If I could compile VS myself, on my own box, that would be massive in ways that are hard to articulate. I wouldn't be contributing to VS. I'd be modifying VS for my own purposes, which is what open source is about.
Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by bunderbunder on Sunday January 11, 2015 @09:16PM
(#8872183)
This isn't big because Microsoft has stared sharing source. The source to the .NET framework has been available _without_ ILSpy for years now.
This is big because Microsoft is truly embracing an open source development model. They've opened most of the .NET platform up to the whole shebang - pull requests, copying code into other projects, forking, all that good stuff.
Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by jenscow on Monday January 12, 2015 @04:05AM
(#8872993)
So the big deal is that we're now allowed to modify the code of a few libraries?
Fair enough.
Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by wernercd on Monday January 12, 2015 @09:39AM
(#8874048)
MS is closed source? People Bitch.
MS moves to open source parts? People Bitch.
Can't win...
Re:We are moving the Roslyn code to GitHub
by brudgers on Monday January 12, 2015 @02:56PM
(#8876031)
My point is that the changes in Microsoft's attitude toward open source have occurred in the open.
It is a response to its parent comment which strongly suggests the attitude reflects a sudden and nefarious change in Microsoft's behaviour.
Really? So they release the source to a few of their developer frameworks and tools, and they're now "all open"?
Don't get me wrong, as a long time C# developer I do appreciate the gesture and I'm especially happy that they're working their "not invented here" mentality, but with simply providing us with the source code that we already have anyway (via ilspy), all of this just seems over-inflated to me.
Let me compile Visual Studio, and I'll be their biggest cheerleader; or IIS, IE... and I'll promise to stop dressing as one.
On buying Github, though? That could be the final 'E' of their strategy.