Re:“Why does a car like the Tesla still have old-style fuses?”
by rdw on Sunday January 11, 2015 @04:02AM
(#8869499)
On top of this, mechanical circuit breakers would have vibration issues when mounted in a moving vehicle. If it's too vibration-resistant, it might not trigger under overcurrent conditions. If it's not vibration-resistant enough, the car flakily breaks on bumpy roads.
Solid-state circuit breakers do exist, and would solve the vibration problem, but some quick Googling didn't turn up anything that looked at all inexpensive.
Re:“Why does a car like the Tesla still have old-style fuses?”
by nmeofthestate on Sunday January 11, 2015 @07:50AM
(#8869838)
Sounds plausible, but if you Google "automotive circuit breaker" you'll find they exist and are quite cheap.
Re:“Why does a car like the Tesla still have old-style fuses?”
by jpindar on Sunday January 11, 2015 @10:21AM
(#8870167)
Mechanical breakers are standard on Harley-Davidson motorcycles. I doubt there's any road vehicle that experiences more vibration than a rigid framed Harley.
They are self-resetting, but make a fairly obvious noise when they reset.
Here's the real deal: a fuse costs cents, and a breaker costs dollars. Fuses rarely blow, so increasing cost two orders of magnitude for an extremely minor benefit doesn't make a lot of cents (har har har). Even Tesla cares about cost control - imagine if the whole car were two orders of magnitude more expensive. I expect that a feedback mechanism would probably actually be cheaper than breakers, since it could be a single, cheap chip rather than expensive mechanical devices.