News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Career in Science Will Cost You Your Firstborn by timr on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:51PM (#8863299)
The whole piece is about how your earning potential rises when you leave academia, so pointing out that your income rose when you left academia isn't really a rebuttal. How much income did you forego during your PhD and post-doc, and how much would you have foregone if you'd stayed?
Re:A Career in Science Will Cost You Your Firstborn by roadnottaken on Friday January 09, 2015 @03:22PM (#8864277)
I made approximately $30k as a grad student (5 yrs) and ~$50k as a post-doc (2.5 yrs). I probably could've made more in a different industry, but it was plenty to live on at the time. It would've been a different story if I'd had kids sooner... anyway, I didn't go into science for the money, I went into it because I like science. I don't disagree with many of the conclusions in the original post, I just wanted to add my anecdotal experience which has been relatively happy and sufficiently-compensated.
Re:A Career in Science Will Cost You Your Firstborn by timr on Friday January 09, 2015 @05:26PM (#8864891)
You may have been satisfied by what you were making, but that doesn't mean that you were making as much as you could have.

I mean, people renounce their belongings and live in ashrams for spiritual reasons, and they're OK with it. But let's not pretend they aren't making a trade-off.

Re:A Career in Science Will Cost You Your Firstborn by roadnottaken on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:25PM (#8865138)
I wasn't trying to pretend. As I said, I went into science because I like science. If I wanted to get paid as much as possible I would've done something else.