Re:'Interface' Considered Harmful
by eveningcoffee on Friday January 09, 2015 @07:49PM
(#8865370)
You can see this as an implementation detail or also as a conceptual detail.
I don't think it's conceptual. It's a technical detail. If they had been implemented differently, this would have made little difference to the programmer using Scala.
Again, Objects aren't Java interfaces, so I guess the whole discussion is moot :)
Re:'Interface' Considered Harmful
by eveningcoffee on Sunday January 11, 2015 @11:05AM
(#8870272)
Yes, this is conceptual as you can conceptually regard functions as objects and it may have great benefits as a tool to communicate the idea to the other people.
There are of course other abstractions with their own benefits.
I disagree. Regardless, Objects aren't Java interfaces, so what are we even discussing?
Uncle Bob wasn't arguing against the general concept of an interface, but about its specific meaning in Java.
Note I think Uncle Bob's condescending tone in TFA is pretty useless. The entire article consists of building a strawman. He really annoys me.