Re:Jeff Atwood Doesn't Know What Autism Is
by btilly on Friday October 16, 2009 @05:02PM
(#886164)
Psychology is prone to having fad diagnoses that lots of people could fit into. For a while everyone is astonished that so many people could be X. And then the popularity of the diagnosis fades, and eventually a lot of the X's turned out to be something else. In extreme cases the X can even cause or turn out to be the result of bad therapy. (For 3 nasty examples read the history of frontal lobotomies, electroshock therapy, and false memory syndrome.)
When the dust settles I am firmly convinced that Aspberger's Syndrome is going to turn out to be one of those fads. Yes, it is a real disorder on the autistic spectrum. Yes, a lot of healthy people are somewhere on this spectrum and feel that the diagnosis fits. Yes, a high proportion of those people are geeks. But there are a lot of people walking around today diagnosed by themselves or others as having Aspberger's who wouldn't have been so diagnosed 20 years ago, and who 20 years from now won't be considered to have a significant handicap that is worth worrying about.
When the dust settles I am firmly convinced that Aspberger's Syndrome is going to turn out to be one of those fads. Yes, it is a real disorder on the autistic spectrum. Yes, a lot of healthy people are somewhere on this spectrum and feel that the diagnosis fits. Yes, a high proportion of those people are geeks. But there are a lot of people walking around today diagnosed by themselves or others as having Aspberger's who wouldn't have been so diagnosed 20 years ago, and who 20 years from now won't be considered to have a significant handicap that is worth worrying about.