News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by snowwrestler on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:26PM (#8858745)
I'd be psyched to get a broadbrand provider that works like my electric company. The rates are reasonable, the power sufficient, the reliability is very high.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rayiner on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:40PM (#8858850)
The electric utility in Chicago just decommissioned a pair of century-old coal plants that were costing the city tens of millions of dollars a year in negative externalities. Yeah, the electric utilities are exactly who I want investing in infrastructure that has becomes obsolete in 5-10 years.
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by snowwrestler on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:16PM (#8860380)
Well my utility is a distribution company, not generation, so their infrastructure is mostly wires and substations. The equivalent for broadband would be fiber cables and switching offices, which seem like they actually could last for a very long time.

Once fiber is run to every house, I can't imagine why it would ever need to be replaced. I think it's actually physically impossible to have a faster data transport medium.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by rayiner on Thursday January 08, 2015 @10:41PM (#8860626)
Didn't we just go through the BPON -> GPON upgrade? If you're just talking about the fiber, you're not even talking about the last mile. It's the last 100 feet. What about all the equipment cabinets in every neighborhood?
Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by snowwrestler on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:54PM (#8863326)
What about them? Once they're sited and hooked into the lines, replacing the gear inside is not difficult.

The question is whether a regulated monopoly could provide good broadband connectivity at a good price. Equipment upgrade scheduling is an implementation detail.

And it's a detail that is already priced into the service. It should be possible for such a monopoly to provide the same level of connectivity as Verizon or Comcast at lower prices, because for their current prices Verizon and Comcast already provide that level of connectivity plus content and software and marketing.

Big ISPs do everything necessary for connectivity, but they also develop and sell products that run on that connectivity. For example Comcast's on-demand and DVR everywhere solutions compete directly with services like Netflix, HBO Go, NBC.com, ESPN 3, etc. Developing, maintaining, and marketing that costs Comcast a lot of money--money that a connectivity-only monopoly would not need to spend.

It would be like if your electric company owned the lines, owned the power station, and sold you appliances like TVs and washing machines. Instead, electric companies just sell electricity, and everyone else sells you things that use electricity. I can't think of a reason that a similar architecture would not work for the Internet.

Re:FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality by venomsnake on Friday January 09, 2015 @01:03AM (#8860967)
Wont decoupling stuff help? Make the last mile maintainer a separate entity.

We need last mile liberation and we need to prevent ISP into entering content business.