News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Is Donating €250k to Charlie Hebdo by sampo on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:07PM (#8858604)
> The right to free speech doesn't justify bad manners.

Yet it protects your rights to have bad manners.

Re:Google Is Donating €250k to Charlie Hebdo by sho_hn on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:30PM (#8858772)
> Yet it protects your rights to have bad manners.

Absolutely.

Here's my idle thoughts, more broadly: I'm not a Muslim. I'm very wary of a breakdown in empathy towards Muslims. There's 1.5 billion of them on our planet, and any outcome other than figuring out how to continue to live together on it seems bleak and undesirable. It's easier to have a dialog with someone (even to the point of changing their minds) if you can be bothered to think a little about how their upbringing and the parameters of their situation affect them, and how those find expression in their lives - what drives their decisions, how they wind up ranking and navigating the same basic human desires we share.

Putting that cartoon on Google's homepage, to me, would be giving up on that, being lazy and picking sides. It's admitting defeat by deciding the world is simpler to act in if we don't bother to understand it.

It also makes it harder for people in bridging positions to function as a channel for this dialog. The bilinguals, the overseas students, that interact with friends and family, that try to explain but end up having to justify cold shoulders.

Check out some indie student music from Arabic countries some time. There's some on YouTube with English translations. Notice all the grappling with their own religion they do, or with gender roles in their society. These aren't dumb, unaware people.

Heck, they're even capable and appreciative of good satire.

Re:Google Is Donating €250k to Charlie Hebdo by dmix on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:55PM (#8858956)
Great response. It takes a strong person to be empathetic and rational in these situations and not just seek out revenge by whatever (even non-violent) means.

But I guess people will always look to the easy and emotional options. Which explains a lot of the 'how' in the 'how we got to this point' question - on both sides.