News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by barry-cotter on Thursday January 08, 2015 @10:05AM (#8856644)
>For someone who already eats correctly (see my other comment in this thread) it's not such a big deal. But then again, you don't see those people on cancer wards as patients too often.

There are plenty of people on cancer wards who had perfectly healthy diets. Most of them are old, because cancer and cardiovascular disease are both primarily diseases of age. There are also cancers like brain cancer, most of which just show up because you were unlucky, not because of any environmental or genetic risk factor. Finally there are plenty of cancers that run in the family like, oh, breast cancer.

So there are tons of people on cancer wards who ate perfectly healthy diets.

Yours, with codial loathing

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by stoicy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @10:20AM (#8856724)
You and I probably disagree on what is a "perfectly healthy diet". But I fully agree with you that whatever the diet, it does not give exactly 100 % immunity for cancer. There are a minority of cancer types that seem to have quite normal cellular metabolism. It's unclear whether diet affects them as much as it affects most cancers such as breast cancer.

I also disagree with you that cancer is primarily a disease of age (or ageing). Age is a contributing factor because the longer one lives, the larger the integral of the contributing effects are. Cancer usually takes quite a long time to form and develop so bad that it starts to cause symptoms.

I agree with you that my tone was too harsh. This is a dear subject for me, and I seldom argue about it, because it's so frustrating. I really have no clue why so much hostility arises around this and dieting in general. Maybe because it's so personal and important for all of us. And so, so hard to study by changing only one variable at a time.

So sorry about my harsh tone. Didn't mean to guilt any cancer patients.