Re:DMCA Copyright Complaint to Google
by nissehulth on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @10:44PM
(#8848769)
Are they going to accept that counter-complaint, coming from a third party? (yes, I should probably read up on DMCA procedures)
GitHub doesn't :( I filed one for the craftbukkit takedown a while back, and got a polite response saying it has to be the content owner.
Re:DMCA Copyright Complaint to Google
by shakethemonkey on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @10:10PM
(#8848669)
Google should raise the bar for those who abuse the DMCA system like this. Maybe require submissions to be in writing, and notarized.
There's a very specific procedure they have to follow outlined in the DMCA law.
Re:DMCA Copyright Complaint to Google
by shakethemonkey on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @03:46AM
(#8849482)
That's true, but there is no legal requirement that Google accept DMCA notices electronically.
Re:DMCA Copyright Complaint to Google
by inigoesdr on Wednesday January 07, 2015 @02:25PM
(#8852680)
I imagine they do because it makes the process easier for them(Google) to manage. Otherwise they would need interns typing out the URLs for all of the tomes that would be coming in every day.
Re:DMCA Copyright Complaint to Google
by adamnemecek on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:02PM
(#8848824)
What an eclectic collection of projects.
Looking at common keywords among the URL's, it appears as though they are merely taking a movie database, googling titles, and submitting complaints for anything containing said title/keyword in the URL (e.g. Pushover, Knockout, Wicked, etc.).
Shady, manipulative, and particularly troubling when the DMCA protocol is "shoot-first" and there is absolutely no oversight or review.
Some kind of punitive penalty for false complaints and a few precedents are needed to put these copyright trolls in their place...
# curl https://www.chillingeffects.org/notices/10275257 | grep github
Thanks for reaching out to us!We have received your legal request. We receive many such complaints each day; your message is in our queue, and we'll get to it as quickly as our workload permits.
Due to the large volume of requests that we experience, please note that we will only be able to provide you with a response if we determine your request may be a valid and actionable legal complaint, and we may respond with questions or requests for clarification. For more information on Google's Terms of Service, please visit http://www.google.com/accounts/TOS
Regards,
The Google Team