Re:How the “Down-Vote” Leads to a Vicious Circle of Negative...
by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @07:21PM
(#8848070)
> That seems to prevent - at least in theory - the whole hivemind behavior.
It might, if "legitimate" evidence, "solid" reasoning, and "respectful" discourse weren't all subjective terms where people's subjective impression will be substantially influenced by agreement/disagreement with the thesis of the post.
> Downvoting: reserve downvotes for posts that are explicitly breaking subreddit rules. Do not downvote someone simply because you disagree with them.
> Upvoting: legitimate evidence, solid reasoning, or respectful discourse; Upvote someone admitting that they are wrong. Upvote outstanding use of logic where evidence can’t be had
That seems to prevent - at least in theory - the whole hivemind behavior. You don't upvote/downvote because you agree, but because you see that there's something good about it, whether or not you share the same point of view.
[1]: http://www.reddit.com/r/NeutralPolitics/comments/ptgxf/meta_...