Re:Ford Tries to Shut Down Independent Repair Tool with Copy...
by monocasa on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @06:52PM
(#8847958)
Ostensibly DMCA claims are made under threat of perjury which is supposed to be the check and balance. That being said I can't think of a single case of that portion of the law being enforced. Unfortunately if a group were to take the action that you suggest, they would forfeit their safe harbor and be able to be sued just as had as the original "infringer". You don't get hardly any leeway in responding to DMCA requests.
Re:Ford Tries to Shut Down Independent Repair Tool with Copy...
by seanflyon on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @07:07PM
(#8848029)
I don't think perjury is an enforceable solution because there is no way to prove that you knew that the claim was invalid. "It seems I was mistaken" or "I disagree with the court's decision" is an iron-clad defense.
Re:Ford Tries to Shut Down Independent Repair Tool with Copy...
by MereInterest on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @06:54PM
(#8847971)
IANAL, so take everything I say with a truck of salt.
The DMCA requires that each takedown notice is made under penalty of perjury. However, the statement is "I believe that this work infringes on my copyright." rather than "This work infringes on my copyright." So long as the person issuing the takedown notice believes that it is valid, there are no consequences.
Re:Ford Tries to Shut Down Independent Repair Tool with Copy...
by lugg on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @06:52PM
(#8847963)
Sounds like a fix for a symptom not the root problem.
Reading about DMCA makes me feel sick to my stomach. Scrap the lot, the resulting mess would probably be less awful than what we have now.
* 1 bad DMCA take-down, no action.
* 2 bad DMCA take-downs, 1 month until future DMCA take-downs accepted.
* 3 bad DMCA take-downs, 2 months...