Now that I've thought about it a bit more, what I'd really love is a directory of sensibly ordered learning resources (free online stuff, videos, links to books on Amazon, whatever), headed by one or two mission-statement type papers (like Lockhart here) for the pedagogical strategy they generally follow, for a whole bunch of topics with several strategies per topic. That way you could pick a topic, read the statements for the various strategies, select one or more that you like and just start working down from the top.
... and I'd also like a pony :-)
http://mathoverflow.net/questions/5074/are-there-elementary-...
...but I too would like to see what you are looking for, at an elementary school age level.