For these institutions, a bankruptcy plan should be required like a fire escape plan is required.
That is what topping up tier 1 capital is about. The bankrupt bank may end up being temporarily partially or wholly owned by the government.
Clearing the books of that juggernaut would still send ripples through the system, likely freeze up credit markets, and wreak stock market havoc. I think Greenspan is right about breaking up such institutions.
I suspect you would then have 100 bankrupt companies instead of one. More careful derivatives regulation is obviously prudent, specifically there really ought to be ring-fenced capital backing up derivative instruments (like is required for proper insurance).
I'm sorry, but your strategy makes no sense to me. You're proposing a plan basically equivalent to the gov. standing ready to pump more (taxpayer) money into GM in case they get into trouble?
I suspect you would then have 100 bankrupt companies instead of one.
You suspect we would have 100 grossly mismanaged companies - that all fail at the same time - instead of one? I don't think so.
That's exactly what happened. The global banking system collapsed remember?
Greenspan's solution is meant to solve the root of the problem. Remove the temptation and, in theory anyway, the government will let banks fail.
Additionally, if you really beleive in institutions that are "too big to fail" then you can't do this. I'm not sure if I do, and at least one person below doesn't, but maybe Greenspan does.
Something like a proper second depression, with a collapse in confidence in almost all banks resulting in massive hoarding, head up north of 20% unemployment. Perhaps we could throw in a world war too.
In fact, if we still calculated unemployment like they did in the thirties - we're ahead of the Great Depression's schedule by about four years (we have the same - adjusted for rule changes enacted by jfk to make the nation's numbers look better - unemployment rate now, one year into the 'recession' As was had five years after the great crash that preceeded the Great Depression)
food for thought. (I'm mobile at the moment, or I'd provide sources)
Strong, sensible banking regulations help prevent situations like this. :(
I believe this second approach is misguided, unrealistic, and frankly juvenile, a position that only those young enough (or cloistered enough) to favour ideology over pragmatics can hold.
It doesn't take much panic for a bank to collapse, owing to how their multipliers work, and when you have three or four banks collapsing around you, it's only reasonable to assume that all banks are dodgy. Getting into that kind of a situation for the sake of an ideological approach to free markets is dangerous, IMHO.
IMO, banks should be small enough that they can fail, and there ought to be a procedure that lets them fail in a relatively clean way. Joe Q. Public should have his savings and deposits protected (up to a limit), and perhaps even small business similarly, but the rest of debt should be converted to equity, and previous shareholders wiped out. But regulations are required, both to limit bank size, and to standardize the procedure so that it's a known quantity (and explicitly removes the bailout moral hazard) and shareholders can apply sufficient pressure to management to avoid self-destruction.
The question is what additional investments you want to allow. I would allow mortgages of high quality (recourse mortgages, size < 2 * earnings and size < 65% of value) when accompanied by appropriate capital.
What planet are you from?
Riiiight.
Humans acting stupidly and making bad decisions happens under all economic and political systems. People say things like, "Capitalism is rocky and prone to booms and busts..." but that's a bit off. Despotism, feudalism, slavery-based economies, communism, and so on have all had booms and busts. Humans make bad decisions regardless of how the conditions are. Regulated/unregulated, free/restricted, decentralized/centralized, it doesn't matter - people make bad decisions in all of these conditions.
Throughout history, once bad decisions are made, people are willing to give themselves over to leaders who promise they have the answers and reassure people. These leaders create new power structures that may or may not help fix the problem. Once the emergency passes, the new power structures are retained and used to further agendas. This gradually leads to a legal code and government with complex and inconsistent laws, which is one of the reasons all nations and empires fall eventually. It's not specifically a capitalism/free market thing at all.