News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Perilous World of Machine Learning for Fun and Profit by danso on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @10:39AM (#8844819)
The OP wrote a great post some time ago (it was posted on HN and was probably how I discovered him): "The Forgotten Job of a Data Science: Editing" http://www.john-foreman.com/blog/the-forgotten-job-of-a-data... theme of that post is similar to the one here:

> In a business, predictive modeling and accuracy is a means, not an end. What’s better: A simple model that’s used, updated, and kept running? Or a complex model that works when you babysit it but the moment you move on to another problem no one knows what the hell it’s doing? Robert Holte argued simplicity versus accuracy in his rather interesting and thoroughly-titled paper “Very Simple Classification Rules Perform Well on Most Commonly Used Datasets.” In that paper, the "air quotes" AI model he used was a single decision stump – one rule. In code, it’d basically be an IF statement. He simply looked through a training dataset and found the single best feature for splitting the data in reference to the response variable and used that to form his rule. The scandalous part of Holte’s approach: his results were pretty good!

The OP has a book (the link is on his site) that I've bought...it purports to teach non-technical people how to do machine learning via Excel...I haven't gone through all of the exercises, mostly because I shudder at having to open Excel to do any kind of data work, but the mental framework that he builds, demonstrating via examples in Excel, is pretty remarkable...I think it's admirable that a data scientist is doing such significant work in demystifying (and maybe even devaluing) his own profession.

Re:The Perilous World of Machine Learning for Fun and Profit by flashman on Sunday January 11, 2015 @11:01PM (#8872441)
I'll just step in and say that, as a non-coder who nevertheless has to understand how code works, Foreman's book "Data Smart" is an invaluable primer on the theory and practice of machine learning.

Certainly I'm no machine learning pro, but as a discipline it's a whole lot less mysterious to me now than it was before I read that book.

Re:The Perilous World of Machine Learning for Fun and Profit by Flimm on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:21AM (#8845076)