Whatever issues those people have with the product might be genuine issues which you would also not be happy about, or the issue might be something you wouldn't mind. I've bought products based on negative reviews purely because whatever the reviewer didn't like about it, it was something I know I would like.
Usually though the reviews won't tell you whether a product is any good, but assuming there are enough reviews on a product the reviews will allow you to determine that certain products really are crap.
I always feel sad rating a movie three stars for "Liked it" on Netflix, because I know that Netflix's rating system is incompatible with the way people assign ratings. Any rating system has to assume that less than half the rating system will be used for neutral-to-positive reviews, and the rest of the system is a big wasteland of varying degrees of "This sucks!" I know the recommendation system doesn't care whether I mean three stars to be positive or not, but it still bothers me.
Is this just an American thing related to the hundred-point scale used in schools, where 69/100 is a failing grade? Or is it universal?
So, if you consistently use three stars to indicate "liked it, reasonably good" and I use it to indicate "waste of time" then our respective recommendations from netflix will be different.
The movies it predicts as 3 stars for me, will be movies I think are a waste of time, and for you would be movies you might find reasonably enjoyable.
Incidentally, I was thinking of replacing my old phone and started reading the negative reviews on Verizon's site. Apparently there's no such thing as a reliable phone that's good at making calls (wish somebody would invent one).
I have one. It's 50 years old and plugs into the wall. :)
My grandparents had this old rotary dial phone, it was black (available in one color!), metal and heavy, really built like a tank. The dial itself was metal and hard to move, and the finger holes weren't beveled so they were sharp and it actually hurt a little to dial the phone.
Eventually they ordered some new service and Bell (remember?) made them turn in the phone.
(Just one little theory of mine: I think star reviews don’t work anymore when it comes to more complex [say, than dog food] things. For those you need to read the written reviews and ignore stars. [And maybe look at the distribution. Finding out that a product is polarising and the reasons for that can be helpful.] If someone rates a camera with one star because it doesn’t film 1080p [a perfectly valid complaint] I don’t care much for his opinion because of different preferences. His written information is nevertheless helpful [I could, after all, care for 1080p], but the information conveyed in his one star rating is close to zero.)